Is it really hard to understand that if someone expresses admiration for a game that has gotten poor critical reception, really bad player reviews and technical problems that more people are going to raise their eyebrows in contrast to a game that has won GOTY by a landslide on this very forum.
Why should I let Gaf's GOTY dictate how I view and discuss opinions? MGS4 won GOTY twice, that alone doesn't automatically validate opinions on this forum from the get go. My GOTY in 2013 came in 7th place, should I view other people's opinions as lesser than mine since people don't share my tastes or perspective?