-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Red Dead Redemption - 360 & PS3 comparison (Bish-approved!)
- Thread starter Mik2121
- Start date
KittyKittyBangBang
Member
CozMick said:
:lol
Dr_Biscuit
Banned
Each first time I see a bird in a video game I try to shoot it down. (MGS + Stinger + Crows = Win).skyfinch said:
hey_it's_that_dog
benevolent sexism
esc said:
Don't worry, there's plenty of pity to go around.
esc said:
The lack of extreme emphasis on presentation does not make someone blind. It means they value other qualities of the game that are still intact and those qualities are not offset by the lessened PQ. Your mileage my vary, obviously - and if it's something that does, in fact, render the version worthless to you, then I do 'feel sorry for you' if you're unable to play the title.
I wasn't talking about what people valued. I was referring to the fact that people seem to think sub-HD vs 720p is a "minor" difference. Maybe if you don't have an HD TV or monitor, sure. I still buy sub-HD titles, but the difference in this case is apparent.Vinci said:
Edit: It was in the context of this thread specifically.
Death Dealer
Member
CozMick said:
:lol
Metalmurphy
Member
CozMick said:
ouch
Mt Heart Attack
Member
This game has the same washed out look that GTA IV had on Ps3... It looks like I'm going to wait for a big price drop before picking up my Ps3 version, used or new.
I'm not going to pay full price for a multiplatform game that looks significantly worse in 20fucking10, I'm just not. It's time for Rockstar to learn, goddamnit.
I'm not going to pay full price for a multiplatform game that looks significantly worse in 20fucking10, I'm just not. It's time for Rockstar to learn, goddamnit.
Windom Earle
Member
JaxJag said:
Indeed! Microsoft has done a lot of things right with the 360. While it may not have the peak performance of the PS3, it has a much less complicated hardware structure, enabling devs to get good performance out of it easily. This is supported by great tools. Reminds me of DC/PS2 times.
Know what makes this thread suck? People complaining that the thread exists and chastising all the people making comparisons and drawing conclusions, not "fanboys taking things too seriously when they should just plaaaay gaaaames, maaaan."
Ban wave incoming.
Ban wave incoming.
indigo-cyclops
Member
Does Gamestop allow opened copies of games to be exchanged, but for a different platform 
? I didn't realize the huge difference in detail..
? I didn't realize the huge difference in detail..flyinpiranha
Member
Majine said:
I think a lot of the reviews were done with the 360 version (most of the ones I've read at least) so a lot of the HD stuff is going to be that. None of the stuff on youtube and such is that great of quality.
Honestly, if you want to play it neither system is bad and just go with where your posse will be!
ClovingWestbrook
Banned
So I purchased the PS3 version and I am in love with the game. My only disappointment is the jaggies. Is the 360 version truly that different even if I am not playing on an HDMI capable system? If it is I will go and exchange the PS3 for the 360 version. Just need some input from you helpful folks.
LordPhoque
Banned
EDIT lol nm.
CaseyTappy
Member
JaxJag said:
Oohh but they did , lets run that chipset to the max and beyond until the heat is on and lights a flashing , we will fix that damn cooling later .
Anyways ,
I will hunt the shops tomorrow for the 360 version although I already ordered and paid for the PS3 version which will now be exclusively for online friends butchering , 360 for Single player and to gaze at the beautiful environment .
Maybe play SP as a total and perverted bastard on one and sickening saint on the other version .
ClovingWestbrook
Banned
Loudninja said:
Because if one system doesn't have the amount of jaggies that the other has, I wouldn't be losing anything but gaining more sharpness visually. Not sure if its that drastic of a difference though especially on an non-HDMI system.
ClovingWestbrook
Banned
INDIGO_CYCLOPS said:Does Gamestop allow opened copies of games to be exchanged, but for a different platform
I just called. If you have the Special Edition for PS3 you won't be able to receive the same for the 360. But they will swap.
indigo-cyclops
Member
LovingSteam said:
Interesting. Thanks for letting me know!
ClovingWestbrook
Banned
INDIGO_CYCLOPS said:
No problem man. If you exchange in the next couple of days please let me know your experience. I am so close to doing it but two things are stopping me: 1) I have 6 hours invested on the PS3 and don't want to start over; and 2) My system isn't HDMI compatible so I am not sure if the jaggies will still be on the 360 version.
30 people axed.
Treat this thread like it's inherently a cesspool and it'll be a cesspool, but it'll be due to the "LOL GAMEFAQS GUYS" and "LOL 4CHANNERS IN THIS THREAD" and "WOW THIS THREAD IS RIDICULOUS GO PLAY GAMES GUYZ," not people trying to make an accurate assessment of the differences in a multiplatform release.
Treat this thread like it's inherently a cesspool and it'll be a cesspool, but it'll be due to the "LOL GAMEFAQS GUYS" and "LOL 4CHANNERS IN THIS THREAD" and "WOW THIS THREAD IS RIDICULOUS GO PLAY GAMES GUYZ," not people trying to make an accurate assessment of the differences in a multiplatform release.
Casualty list, please.EviLore said:
This is what I'd like to know, but "bad" is subjective. Safe bet is to wait for the digitalfoundry comparison. I'm certain they're working on that as I type this.
I can deal with a dip to the low-20s when action gets hectic, nothing more than that.
Takuan said:
Ranger X
LordPhoque
Verapamil
scoobs
Billy Mitchell
Tom Penny
reKon
NHale
White Sharingan
Fix The Scientist
Timbuktu
Jtones
Otrebor Nightmarecoat
lethial
Launch
wizword
Felix Lighter
jaypah
SamBa
WickedLaharl
CozMick
DMPrince
RandomVince
acevans2
KratosKilla
Duke Togo
UFRA
Esteban
Lots of juniors not coming back.
hey guys the game still doesnt come out here so i still have a day to decide.
my question is, on your tv u have the option for sharpness or something could that make a difference for the ps3 version being a little blurry
also if i dont care about graphics and only about framerate, how does that compare to the 360 version cuz i realy dont wanna search 100 pages =P
my question is, on your tv u have the option for sharpness or something could that make a difference for the ps3 version being a little blurry
also if i dont care about graphics and only about framerate, how does that compare to the 360 version cuz i realy dont wanna search 100 pages =P
CaseyTappy
Member
LovingSteam said:
Didn't Magnus compare the 360 version on Component with the HDMI PS3 version in the original thread and found less jaggies on the 360 ?
ClovingWestbrook
Banned
CaseyTappy said:
Hmm I think you're right. Thanks for reminding me. I will tell you, being the decisive bastard that I am is simply not fun lol.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Omiee said:
You can raise your TV's sharpness but if the textures are inherently blurry it's not gonna do much to the image quality, the PS3 version uses QAA which is prone to making the entire screen a lot blurry than standard MSAA.
On the frame rate, many people have said it's better than GTA IV, but some have also said it's noticeably bad compared to the 360. So if you played and lived with the PS3 version of GTA IV, this is definitely better than that.
Cat in the Hat
Member
You know I for one am amazed that Rockstar can make the game look this good on such underpowered tech. Wonder what is looks like on there PCs. . .drools*
ClovingWestbrook
Banned
Chrange said:
I'd have done it better, but I'm at work :lol
LOL! LOVE HIM.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Sticky