-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Gafia 2: The Bride of Gafia |Mafia OT| One Wedding, Many Funerals
- Thread starter RetroMG
- Start date
They will not care two shits about the arsonist. Which is what the arsonist wants and why I expect he targets people he don't expect of being scum.
Kinda my point. I don't think we can count on scum to do town's dirty work.
Xamtheking
Member
Well
I'm fine with lynching someone who has a lot of holes
Regardless of scum or arso
You're lumping me in the same non-active blendy list as BSP?
Accuse me of being wrong on two of my biggest hunches, sure (Scrafty and Xam), but this? C'mon. I said it myself I don't have a strong feeling elsewhere after those two were revealed to be town, so now I have the tough position of who to throw my vote behind.
You guys get so antsy when someone doesn't vote for a while, huh. As I said before, I'm trying to pick between Kalor and AB, based completely on whether or not I think it's best to try to scum hunt or try to snuff out the arso. To be clear, I feel more strongly about AB being the arsonist than I do Kalor being scum (because of math!). That being said, I do want to scum hunt more than I want to kill the arsonist. Ouro could be scum, after all.
VOTE: Kalor
Also, where the hell is RNH?
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
As in, scum isn't going to kill either of them.
AbsolutBro
Member
Super defensive is over selling it. I am more frustrated that no one can give me a solid reason I can actually defend. As for disappearing, I had reasons.
Unless of course scum kills one of us.
When it comes to Wee not fake claiming I completely forgot that she kinda claimed ordinary in her first post.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
I'm saying they won't.
Scratch that...
The trust part in the second sentence is interesting.I asked him if there was anything he felt comfortable sharing in private. He said he trusted me and bronx and claimed his role. Then he and me started discussing how to best use it. I proposed the idea that if he still had one shot left, he should claim to be a one shot (making scum think he is not a danger to them and another day switch would take them by surprise) and if he had used both shots, he should claim to be three shot (making scum think another switch COULD happen, and maybe they would "waste" a kill/power dealing with a now ordinary Xam). He basically reacted that he would do that and called me an owlbear
Also, he gave me a code word that I could use if I wanted the seating to be switched around. This was the thing that made me think he isn't scum or the arsonist. It is not impossible this power is scum/neutral aligned, but I doubt he would have given me basically control of his power if that was the case.
When did you start trusting Roy, Xam? You seemed doubtful of his claim of being doused and that wouldn't be weird if you're town and not lying.
And if you don't mind, could you go through how the gossip went from your perspective? Like, did you want to claim the moment you entered the gossip or were you hesitating?
Xamtheking
Member
i thought roy was gossip chat man at first
Your pinkie is still there right? We just can't see it?
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
I don't know why we're even doubting AB is the arsonist. He has no contradictory claim. He's done fuckall to refute it except say "but you're wrong tho," all dancing around the actual subject of the arsonist.
Xamtheking
Member
this is a true fact
VOTE: AbsolutBro
I wasn't. It was just a thought experiment.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
Oh, that actually wasn't directed at you in particular. I was mostly yelling at the sky. I saw why you asked that. I still think he should answer it.
ok Launch, i think i will spill some beans. I dont care about a AB lynch today. how do you feel about that ?
Launch will respond in a second. Just relax and dont spill the beans!
Exactly, if you give out vital information this early in the game it will hinder the late game !
You better shut up now or you will get yourself killed at night !
Ok Ok, you convinced me. Everyone Proceed now
what if he turns out to be vanilla Townie ?`Who will be your second choice `?
no shit talking. I dont know anything about AB but i have vital information about 3 players.
If it comes out that would put AB on the back for today.
You do realise that making statements like this is putting a huge bullseye on your back for the next night?
Well, i wont be surviving the night after making those remarks.I will surely get mauled. Might aswell lead town to some real threads.
Well' I'll assume you'll then tell your vital information today.
i will. After watching taht shitshow of today i might aswell go all in and just go and tell everyone.
Bananaspaceprincess
Neo Member
Ok nin, you are soft claiming... again.
Bananaspaceprincess
Neo Member
Nin, are you saying our current suspects, Kalor, RNH, AB, CTim,... are not a threat for town and we should change our course?
What is the reason you want to share your info now?
What is the reason you want to share your info now?
All of those above can be scum i am not denying it. What i am saying is that i have infirmation that could lead us to other suspects that blended it and were not really suspects up to this point. It is a win / win situation for town since the view will be broadened.
TDLR; i have shit to share
Bananaspaceprincess
Neo Member
I know were you're going nin! Just spill the beans plz?
well DUH! but no that doesnt count BSP thats cheating ! Sorry
swiper no swiping swiper no swiping SWIPER NO SWIPING