It's better than the Galaxy games. Deal with it.
Joke of the Year
It's better than the Galaxy games. Deal with it.
Ah, sure. Because it's ok for other people to ignore the OTHER half of the sentence, right?
Shit posting at it's finest. When you respond with a gif it's clear you have no counter point
People insinuate that somehow the opinions are wrong and that TLoU, MGS3, or something like SFII etc should have absolutely made the top 20 in lists like these. Just because those people feel that way doesn't mean everyone else should/does.
Dark Souls as the best game of all time? LMAO. It's easily my favorite game of the last decade, but it's nowhere near the best game of "all time".
I would swap ROTTR for TR2013 tbh, that game makes more sense
Despite popular GAF opinion, it's not the best game ever made. Not that anything below the top ten makes a whole lot of sense anyway though.
That really is one of the worst "best ever" lists I have ever seen.
It fails even as a talking point.
But there's no Super Metroid, Frank.A subjective ranked list! Gaf will be rational about this!
Is Shenmue in it?
Ok no TLoU but RotTR is there? In the top 20, no less? Insanity.The last of us has nothing on angry birds in terms of impact.
not one souls game throw this list in the trash
It doesn't make sense no matter how you look at it. That's one reason why it's a terrible list.But I always wonder -- do they mean, if you played all those games today? Or for when they were released? Or for their influence in the overall picture of gaming?
Bioshock so low, with an NFL game just above it. Christ.
No The Last of Us at top 10, so it's a better list than I expected
You liking a game doesn't make it the best game ever. The Souls games Shouldn't even be a contender, everything considered.
NFL 2K5 is flat-out a better game than BioShock. So is Tecmo Super Bowl. That's two, count 'em, two NFL games that are better than BioShock.
I know that people here sometimes have a hard time wrapping their heads around the high quality of great sports games, but that doesn't make them bad games.
Oh, super glad to see Rise of the Tomb Raider here. Was my GOTY last year, it's just outstanding, so cannot complain with that pick.
No FFVI or FFVII in the Top 10. Or Chrono Trigger
so edgy, etc
It's a top 50, I know it's totally worthless to argue but hey..
IMO
ROTTR shouldn't be there. Tomb Raider 2 should.
MK2 should take MK's spot. MK was obliterated by its sequel.
Street Fighter 2 should be somewhere with Tekken 2 or VF2 to represent the 3D fighters.
Also, where the hell is Journey? Shadow of the Colossus??
What about the original Resident Evil or RE2?? I respect the fact that RE4 made it but RE is pretty much the father of horror games, even more when you read the reasons why Wolfenstein is in there... The Last of Us, no?
There should also be an arcade racer somewhere; at least Outrun or Top Gear or Burnout 3. And Sonic 2... And my personal pick SOTN.
No Super Metroid in the top 50?
Why so much hate for ROTTR here?
It's best TR game in more than 10 years, i honestly don't see what's wrong with it. Game deserves to be on the list, maybe not in TOP 20, but there really isn't anything wrong with game being on the list. I repeat it's best TR game in more than 10 years and this is deserved.
Because you can't consider a game without considering its flaws and the Souls games have problems from technical and otherwise. It isn't enough to grade a game on what it wanted to do. 'The best game ever' mantra should be as close as you can get to a 'perfect game'. And that includes all aspect of the game. The same goes for any 'best ever' list. At least that's what I think.It is as much as a contender as everything else. Why wouldn't it be?
That's quite a leap in logic. So just because TLOU is from the same studio that made a game (that's not even TLOU) that inspired Crystal to reboot TR, that means people can't prefer ROTR to TLOU (or even Uncharted)? What the fuck am I reading here?
"Besides the things I listed". So you agree that TR has better exploration? That was one of that poster's points. So why don't people discuss the merits of both games instead of posting stupid gif replies?
Ah, sure. Because it's ok for other people to ignore the OTHER half of the sentence, right?
The poster straight up dismissed TLOU as less impactful than ROTTR which obviously made no sense because, again, TLOU is one of the most critically acclaimed games of last gen that had a huge impact on Pop Culture and secondly, the ROTTR wouldn't be the way it is without ND making the Uncharted series
was the only one to make me double-take. I haven't played it so can't judge but... yeah, it came as a surprise.
If that was true then you should have Half Life 1 instead of Half life 2, half life 1 had a much larger impact on the entire genre of fps games then HL2 did
That's the problem with all these lists that try to rank based off impact. They never stick to that for the entire list and then you end up with CoD2, Starcraft 2 and other games on here that make no sense in the context of the list.