Oh God, I woke up to this and nearly fell out my chair.
Screw the haters, this looks AWESOME. It's what I've always imagined a 3D handheld Pokemon game could and should be. And contrary to what some people are saying, I think the battle animations and art are a perfect evolution from the 2D games. It's about as close to the 2D action it can get while still remaining 3D. And I love that Frog starter, he's my go-to this game.
That said, I have two things I PRAY they fix from Gen V;
1. We need Evolutions from prior Pokemon, I hated that about Black and White. One of my favorite things about new Pokemon games is seeing what evolutions they bring for old Pokemon. Seriously, we need a Heracross evo this gen.
2. ALL Starters need secondary types. The fact that only one of the Gen V starters had a secondary type really made the selection kinda lame for starters. And dear God, no more Fire/Fighting for the Fire starter, original typings for the starters goes a long way for making them unique and memorable.
If they fix those small gripes, This could easily be one of the best if they do it right.