Support NeoGAF

user_nat · Nov 11, 2011

Road said:
I think there has been confirmation it was actually in order.

Must have missed that one. Wasn't a very popular idea earlier this year.
Infact one month Evilore posted that the order did not reflect sales at the start of the OP.

Kusagari · Nov 11, 2011

By the way: Does this make Dark Souls the first non Tekken/Soulcalibur Scamco game to chart in years?

test_account · Nov 11, 2011

PS3 250k, 3DS 250k. The 3DS is truly Nintendo's answer to the PS3 hehe

(so far at least).

REMEMBER CITADEL · Nov 11, 2011

Elios83 said:
So:

[360] 393K
[PS3] 275K
[3DS] 250K
[Wii]225k
[DS] 180K

Great month for the 360, PS3 is slightly higher yoy, Wii slightly down.
3DS did nice numbers but it's still not taking off.
Better than I expected numbers for the DS.
Overall it wasn't a really good month for my predictions :/

PS3 is 250k or less:

Regarding hardware specifically, Frazier commented: The Xbox 360 was the top-selling hardware platform for the month, realizing a unit sales increase of over 20% versus last October. The 3DS was the second best-selling hardware platform, with combined 3DS/DS sales up over 25% from last October.

Nintendo sold more than 675,000 combined hardware units in October. This includes more than 250,000 units of Nintendo 3DS, nearly 250,000 Wii systems and nearly 180,000 units of the Nintendo DS family of systems.

allan-bh · Nov 11, 2011

Someone create a new thread

Road · Nov 11, 2011

user_nat said:
Must have missed that one. Wasn't a very popular idea earlier this year.

Lots of confusion is expected, since we don't have the actual numbers. =\

Gadfly · Nov 11, 2011

Nuclear Muffin said:
It's been standard NPD procedure for a while now. Largest contributing platform goes on the left and cascades downwards as it goes towards the right. So in this case, PS3 was the biggest platform for Dark Souls.

So PS3 fans will have something to cheer about! Expect this to be mentioned over and over again

Aika'svyse · Nov 11, 2011

Looking at 360 Black Friday deals, i think Pachter might be right about it having the biggest hardware period ever

Nuclear Muffin · Nov 11, 2011

Right, I'm off to bed. Would some kind soul endevour to get Layton 4, Tetris Axis and Kirby Return to Dreamland's NPD sales please? (Oh and Kirby Mass Attack's 2nd month would be great too!)

I hope to wake up to see these!

NavNucST3 · Nov 11, 2011

Aika'svyse said:
Looking at 360 Black Friday deals, i think Pachter might be right about it having the biggest hardware period ever

If they produce enough, this: "Xbox 360 4GB console with Kinect plus a $50 Walmart gift card for $199, starting at 10 p.m." is going to move a lot of units.

Aselith · Nov 11, 2011

Kusagari said:
By the way: Does this make Dark Souls the first non Tekken/Soulcalibur Scamco game to chart in years?

Depends on how many years. I think that Ace Combat 6 charted.

Aika'svyse · Nov 12, 2011

NavNucST3 said:
If they produce enough, this: "Xbox 360 4GB console with Kinect plus a $50 Walmart gift card for $199, starting at 10 p.m." is going to move a lot of units.

Yup getting one for my sister. although the other one is getting ps3, she already owns 360

donny2112 · Nov 18, 2011

Since most of the numbers have not been released (NeoGAF thread uses ranges for the most part), no numbers in the results given. For the rankings, the positions are just a counter. If two people are actually tied, it isn't shown here. As usual, annual points are being kept up with behind-the-scenes, but they're just not shown here.

NeoGAF Prediction Results - October 2011

Units

1. Megadragon15
2. rayner
3. Dedication Through Light
4. doicare
5. Ydahs
6. donny2112
7. BLaZiN PRopHeT
8. Hammer24
9. Hiro_Kunimi_80
10. pitseleh
11. GAF_Agg
12. ItWasMeantToBe19
13. jvm
14. archnemesis
15. Pachter
16. SuperBanjo
17. Indyana
18. tonitoni
19. Coxy
20. Horns
21. NateDrake
22. noobie
23. Osuwari
24. rostocker
25. Jokeropia
26. Orgen
27. confuziz
28. uchihasasuke
29. MasterShotgun
30. Averon
31. Road
32. Teetris
33. Brakara
34. walking fiend
35. botticus
36. skedar897
37. SonicX_Zero
38. LOCK
39. NeoUltima
40. Saiyar
41. siyrobbo
42. Elios83
43. Zero-Crescent
44. Strike
45. Jonsoncao
46. starship
47. Jesse2040
48. Flea
49. Goldmund
50. Hydderf
51. baekshi
52. allan-bh
53. Zeppelin
54. mik83kuu
55. CrankyKong
56. Gadfly
57. Thoraxes
58. Kung Fu Grip

Points

Code:

     October 2011                Overall 2011 (Top 8/10 months)
1.   Megadragon15       ---.--   Zero-Crescent       ---.--
2.   rayner             ---.--   Pachter             ---.--
3.   Dedication Through ---.--   Elios83             ---.--
4.   doicare            ---.--   NeoUltima           ---.--
5.   donny2112          ---.--   confuziz            ---.--
6.   NateDrake          ---.--   Road                ---.--
7.   Ydahs              ---.--   doicare             ---.--
8.   BLaZiN PRopHeT     ---.--   archnemesis         ---.--
9.   Hammer24           ---.--   donny2112           ---.--
10.  Hiro_Kunimi_80     ---.--   pitseleh            ---.--
11.  pitseleh           ---.--   Indyana             ---.--
12.  archnemesis        ---.--   Hiro_Kunimi_80      ---.--
13.  Pachter            ---.--   Teetris             ---.--
14.  Indyana            ---.--   jvm                 ---.--
15.  noobie             ---.--   Strike              ---.--
16.  tonitoni           ---.--   Jesse2040           ---.--
17.  ItWasMeantToBe19   ---.--   SuperBanjo          ---.--
18.  Horns              ---.--   rostocker           ---.--
19.  jvm                ---.--   rayner              ---.--
20.  SuperBanjo         ---.--   BLaZiN PRopHeT      ---.--
21.  Coxy               ---.--   Saiyar              ---.--
22.  Teetris            ---.--   Ydahs               ---.--
23.  Orgen              ---.--   botticus            ---.--
24.  walking fiend      ---.--   Megadragon15        ---.--
25.  Jokeropia          ---.--   Brakara             ---.--
26.  Road               ---.--   Jonsoncao           ---.--
27.  Averon             ---.--   Orgen               ---.--
28.  Osuwari            ---.--   andy_lhc            ---.--
29.  Brakara            ---.--   Dedication Through L---.--
30.  uchihasasuke       ---.--   Goldmund            ---.--
31.  confuziz           ---.--   skedar897           ---.--
32.  skedar897          ---.--   Jokeropia           ---.--
33.  rostocker          ---.--   Osuwari             ---.--
34.  botticus           ---.--   SonicX_Zero         ---.--
35.  MasterShotgun      ---.--   Hammer24            ---.--
36.  SonicX_Zero        ---.--   starship            ---.--
37.  siyrobbo           ---.--   siyrobbo            ---.--
38.  starship           ---.--   allan-bh            ---.--
39.  LOCK               ---.--   uchihasasuke        ---.--
40.  Elios83            ---.--   ItWasMeantToBe19    ---.--
41.  NeoUltima          ---.--   NateDrake           ---.--
42.  Saiyar             ---.--   perfectchaos007     ---.--
43.  Zero-Crescent      ---.--   noobie              ---.--
44.  Jesse2040          ---.--   tonitoni            ---.--
45.  Jonsoncao          ---.--   kefka2030           ---.--
46.  Strike             ---.--   Credo               ---.--
47.  Flea               ---.--   bakemono            ---.--
48.  Hydderf            ---.--   jamesinclair        ---.--
49.  mik83kuu           ---.--   Scott32020          ---.--
50.  allan-bh           ---.--   AdventureRacing     ---.--

Congratulations, Megadragon15!

Dedication Through Light · Nov 18, 2011

Ah he beat me by two places, lol, congrats.

I guess this was my best month, 3 and Im finally in the top 30

orion434 · Nov 18, 2011

Sweet! Highest rank-in at #2! Bumped me up to Rank 19 for the year! One of these days I'd be #1!

Support NeoGAF

October 2011 NPD Predictions - closes November 7

user_nat

THE WORDS! They'll drift away without the _!

Kusagari

Member

test_account

XP-39C²

REMEMBER CITADEL

Banned

allan-bh

Member

Road

Member

Gadfly

While flying into a tree he exclaimed "Egad!"

Aika'svyse

Banned

Nuclear Muffin

Banned

NavNucST3

Member

Aselith

Member

Aika'svyse

Banned

donny2112

Member

Dedication Through Light

Member

orion434

Member

Similar threads