• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Winter of Anime 2013 |OT -5| This is stupid, kayos90 sucks!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Envelope

sealed with a kiss
ryan2.gif

Bebop the Cowboy then?
 
DokiDoki is gonna suck.

I mean I've been favouring making a Precure thread for months, but it's not like a similar thread stopped people from talking about K-ON in here.

I still think you should. You'll find a lot more fans of Precure here on GAF if you do. Would be a good vessel to try and get others to watch the shows as well.
 

Envelope

sealed with a kiss
Not necessarily. I'd rather just recommend to people something that's actually good from outside this season rather than recommending just because it's currently airing.

But on the other hand, watching something in a group can easily elevate something that is average since you have all that camaraderie and can commiserate or celebrate together. ^^
 

Jex

Member
[Smile PreCure] - 5

You know, Sailor Moon had better transformation sequences than this. Also, Cure Happy looks really constipated when she's charging her special move.
But on the other hand, watching something in a group can easily elevate something that is average since you have all that camaraderie and can commiserate or celebrate together. ^^

That is certainly an accurate statement. I won't disagree with you in this.
 

madp

The Light of El Cantare
Little Witch Academia General

Why haven't you voted in the AotYs yet? Today's the final day!

I still think you should. You'll find a lot more fans of Precure here on GAF if you do. Would be a good vessel to try and get others to watch the shows as well.

On the other hand, it's likely to be a miserable failure because I would boycott it, killing most of the activity!

also all of the other wayward Precure fans are PopGAF and do you really want that unholy union to exist
 

Regulus Tera

Romanes Eunt Domus
Everyone should just watch Wandering Son. Even if you've seen it already.
Better yet, everyone should watch Goldfish Warning! with me.
I still think you should. You'll find a lot more fans of Precure here on GAF if you do. Would be a good vessel to try and get others to watch the shows as well.
I suck at making banners. Plus last two times I made a thread for video games a) Sin & Punishment 2 ended bombing, and b) Golden Sun 3 ended sucking.
[Smile PreCure] - 5

You know, Sailor Moon had better transformation sequences than this. Also, Cure Happy looks really constipated when she's charging her special move.
I told you you were watching the wrong show! I watched 110 episodes of Legend of the Galactic Heroes for you, the least you could do is throw me a bone here.

P.S. You should skip straight to Smile 35. You are gonna love that one.
HeartCatch Precure - 31

Okay, noooow I can understand why Yuri is a jerk.
This arc is one of my favourites.
Cologne. ;_;
 

Syrinx

Member
The iDOLM@STER 9

Beginning was obviously filming, but still pretty cool.

Then somebody eats Iori's pudding and Ami and Mami decide to play detective to find the culprit, even though it's Iori's fault for not putting her name on her pudding. This is what you do when you put stuff in a communal fridge. Then they make up an introduction for themselves plagiarized entirely from other, better material (not necessarily the show, but certainly better than these two jerkoffs. Though Sailor Moon > iDOLMASTER, even though that reference was pulled out of nowhere and made no sense. But it's Ami and Mami, so it shouldn't be surprising that they're totally sucking).

For whatever reason, the others decide to go along with their whole thing instead of just saying "No, we're not playing your stupid little detective game. Get over your pudding, Iori" like they should have. They discover that (SUPER MASSIVE LIFE-RUINING SPOILER)
Miki was the one who ate the pudding.
 

Dresden

Member
At the very least, beyond the fact that they get caught by that one older dude and led away with the (iirc) threat of their powers being removed, that episode's first 10 minutes has no direct impact. There really isn't any time to reflect.
The exposition has immediate impact on their lives (which is a good thing). Reflection comes in the wake of these events, leading into the start of the next arc and forms a good part of the subtext for what happens in those episodes. Like a lot of things about the show, it could be handled in a better way, but it's hard to dwell on its deficiencies as you move along, and see those concepts explored in detail. It's easy to say this in hindsight, but even in the context of just having watched the episode, there's faith in the competence of the writing to carry things through, and in having that long 'dump' be something worthwhile.

Buried somewhere in that long ramble about 'syfy' is the explanation as to just why you can't enjoy it, though. A diet of shitty syfy shows as a youth would turn anyone off these things, but then, no one forced a young firehawk12 to watch Stargate or Lost, either. The latter might explain the lack of faith in any serialized tv.

I'm not spamming as such, rather I am communicating through moving images. Just like anime.

I'm glad I live in a post-image world.
 
On the other hand, it's likely to be a miserable failure because I would boycott it, killing most of the activity!

also all of the other wayward Precure fans are PopGAF and do you really want that unholy union to exist
I'm sure there are more lurking about, and PopGAF aren't bad people.
I suck at making banners. Plus last two times I made a thread for video games a)Sin & Punishment 2 ended bombing, and b)Golden Sun 3 ended sucking.

Are you saying making the thread is somehow going to retroactively make Heartcatch suck/bomb?
 
Amnesia 04


Man, the jackets everyone is wearing is pretty distracting since it basically blends into the trees.

Pretty much concludes his route in a nice tidy matter.

I kept expecting that since his route was finishing up, that the otome lead was going to have an accident somehow. Fall down the stairs, fireworks accident, something was going to happen. Of course, it was a truck that came out of nowhere. That was hilarious.

At least I am enjoying how this show is doing the whole otome adapation.
 

madp

The Light of El Cantare
[Smile PreCure] - 5

You know, Sailor Moon had better transformation sequences than this. Also, Cure Happy looks really constipated when she's charging her special move.

Smile's transformations are bad, but the franchise is capable of much better.

And kiai constipation is a real problem, man. If we could all generate kiai without straining, then how could we show our GUTS and DETERMINATION?
 

Dynedom

Member
Hrm, final Hellsing OVA was a monologue-fest. Still had some great highlights but I'm kinda left with a...I dunno...dry feeling. It seems somewhat anticlimactic.

Maybe I need to watch this series through before I comment on this final OVA in a proper review. Maybe some people will enjoy it because for once it's not an action set piece with a speech at the beginning and end, haha.

edit: I'm getting a real Kara no Kyoukai/Garden of Sinners finale feel from this last episode (except for the fact that it wasn't a boring pile of shit).
 
Amnesia 04



Man, the jackets everyone is wearing is pretty distracting since it basically blends into the trees.

Pretty much concludes his route in a nice tidy matter.

I kept expecting that since his route was finishing up, that the otome lead was going to have an accident somehow. Fall down the stairs, fireworks accident, something was going to happen. Of course, it was a truck that came out of nowhere. That was hilarious.

At least I am enjoying how this show is doing the whole otome adapation.

Wait Shin's route isnt the whole anime?! :(
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
The exposition has immediate impact on their lives (which is a good thing). Reflection comes in the wake of these events, leading into the start of the next arc and forms a good part of the subtext for what happens in those episodes. Like a lot of things about the show, it could be handled in a better way, but it's hard to dwell on its deficiencies as you move along, and see those concepts explored in detail. It's easy to say this in hindsight, but even in the context of just having watched the episode, there's faith in the competence of the writing to carry things through, and in having that long 'dump' be something worthwhile.

Buried somewhere in that long ramble about 'syfy' is the explanation as to just why you can't enjoy it, though. A diet of shitty syfy shows as a youth would turn anyone off these things, but then, no one forced a young firehawk12 to watch Stargate or Lost, either. The latter might explain the lack of faith in any serialized tv.

I'd rather watch a show that just doesn't have any of these problems though. Such a show is seemingly impossible to make when it comes to anything related to genre fiction unfortunately.

Amnesia 04

Man, the jackets everyone is wearing is pretty distracting since it basically blends into the trees.

Pretty much concludes his route in a nice tidy matter.

I kept expecting that since his route was finishing up, that the otome lead was going to have an accident somehow. Fall down the stairs, fireworks accident, something was going to happen. Of course, it was a truck that came out of nowhere. That was hilarious.

At least I am enjoying how this show is doing the whole otome adapation.

Wait wait wait... is this Amagami SS with a female lead? lol

Also, I just noticed that the dude is wearing two collars the other day.
 

darkside31337

Tomodachi wa Mahou
[Smile PreCure] - 5

You know, Sailor Moon had better transformation sequences than this. Also, Cure Happy looks really constipated when she's charging her special move.


That is certainly an accurate statement. I won't disagree with you in this.

Man you just flipping crazy.

Yayoi has one of the greatest transformation sequences of all time.
 

SDBurton

World's #1 Cosmonaut Enthusiast
HeartCatch Precure - 32

So
the guy that kept saving the girls whenever they were in a pinch earlier in the series was just Coppe in disguise?
Did not see that coming. :lol
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
Firebro sure has been typing a whole lot of words just to say he doesn't want to watch SSY.
Well, I want to be clear that it's not some kind of irrational hate or anything. I've actually thought this stuff through. lol

What problems?
He doesn't want to break Brandy's heart. Sometimes its just easier to be honest!
Haha, nice timing.

I think this has to be Sentai's best cover and disc arts yet. Cant wait.
Nonoha is on the third dvd art
From the mind that brought us Sailor Moon, Aria and Kaleido Star...
 

Kagami

Member
So , is there anything interesting this season ? Need some recommendations.

There are a lot of sequels, so check out the list in the OP and see if you liked any of the previous seasons of those.

For new stuff, my favorite at the moment is Kotoura-san.
Also enjoying Vividred Operation despite my complaints about it.
 

/XX/

Member
Dresden's first post made me eager to continue watching From the New World soon, but it happens that sometimes I'm not sure if Dresden's posts are totally serious! The later one he made discussing it made me sure it was genuine; sounds really good. Thanks for your impressions!

But this time she's doing it during the opening. That's a certain someone's territory.
Yeah, it is really a bigger offense and all... but seeing what you did with that 'other Makoto' image I don't think she deserves nearly that much hate!
 

Shergal

Member
It's interesting how this thread has turned into Precure OT, this can only lead to a lot of people watching and whining about Dokidoki when it starts.

I have to say that I've never watched any Precure show except for Heartcatch, and that's because it had Umakoshi on board. I don't know if I want to join the bandwagon...
 

Envelope

sealed with a kiss
It's interesting how this thread has turned into Precure OT, this can only lead to a lot of people watching and whining about Dokidoki when it starts.

I have to say that I've never watched any Precure show except for Heartcatch, and that's because it had Umakoshi on board. I don't know if I want to join the bandwagon...

Watch Smile because it's also good and then join us as we suffer through DokiDoki.
 

Branduil

Member
Well, I want to be clear that it's not some kind of irrational hate or anything. I've actually thought this stuff through. lol

Yeah, but the thing is that it seems like most of your criticisms relate to other shows and not From the New World, since you haven't watched it past episode five. The show doesn't do what you're afraid of it doing.

I guess the lesson here is watching bad shows can ruin good shows for people.
 

Dynedom

Member
So both seasons of Arakawa Under the Bridge are going up on CR in about four hours. Anyone know anything about it? Seems interesting.

It always struck me as one of those shows where you really need to be either Japanese or very accustomed to things/quirks/factoids/customs within Japan to appreciate. You can still watch it but I feel like I'm only getting half the laughs.
 
Noir 20-21

These episodes have been pretty rough to say the least.
Kirika being the one who killed Mireille's parents was surprising for a number of reasons. Isn't Kirika several years younger than her? They looked about the same age in the flashback but Kirika is clearly old enough now to be a high school student while I assumed Mireille to be in her mid to upper twenties. I'm really not sure how this will go on for five more episodes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom