-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Community Season 3 |OT| Six Seasons and a Movie... feels Goodman!
- Thread starter Medalion
- Start date
- Status
roosters93
Member
:/
Horrible episode. Started out great, and went downhill extremely fast. I felt like I was watching a bad live action episode of Spongebob between scenes like Jeff hulking out and the stupid graphic stuff.
Im a person who has yet to feel truly disappointed in a episode of this show until tonight. I also normally love it when this show takes its flights of fancy like Season 2 or this season's musical opener. I really hope this isn't indicative of the quality for the rest of the season D=
EDIT- ^ UGGGGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH GROAN MOAN WHINE
Fuckbags horsebag gamegold
I dont know whether to be upset more at more bad cartoon graphic gags or a severe lack of ian duncan.
Im a person who has yet to feel truly disappointed in a episode of this show until tonight. I also normally love it when this show takes its flights of fancy like Season 2 or this season's musical opener. I really hope this isn't indicative of the quality for the rest of the season D=
EDIT- ^ UGGGGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH GROAN MOAN WHINE
Fuckbags horsebag gamegold
I dont know whether to be upset more at more bad cartoon graphic gags or a severe lack of ian duncan.
It was a decent episode. I don't mind the silliness but it's definitely not accessible for first time viewers.
My parents watched for the first time tonight. My dad didn't like it and said he was really lost at the dreamatorium scene. I think this season really relies on having watched the first two seasons to truly "get" it. It's the same way I felt about The Office the first time I watched a random episode. Didn't understand the humor or characters and really disliked it. Then I gave it a chance and watched from the beginning and it ended up becoming one of my favorite shows ever.
My parents watched for the first time tonight. My dad didn't like it and said he was really lost at the dreamatorium scene. I think this season really relies on having watched the first two seasons to truly "get" it. It's the same way I felt about The Office the first time I watched a random episode. Didn't understand the humor or characters and really disliked it. Then I gave it a chance and watched from the beginning and it ended up becoming one of my favorite shows ever.
Hot Coldman
Banned
The graphics do need to go away. This continuing use of visual effects detracts from the fact the show's actors and writers are performing at a level higher than nearly everyone else out there just with normal tools. Ditch the gimmickry. It's not damaging yet but it's unnecessary and unwelcome.
More stuff like the anime scene in ep9 are welcome, however.
More stuff like the anime scene in ep9 are welcome, however.
I really loved the timecard gag from last weeks episode. The visual effect stuff tonight didn't have that kind of punch, and also had a really cheap low-budget feel that I don't normally associate with this show.
It feels gimmicky and cartoony for the sake of being gimmicky and cartoony. Not because its actually funny or right for the show
Hot Coldman
Banned
A big part of why the stuff worked last week is because it never happens. Now it's happened twice in a row, and I'm less pleased about that. Chances are it's mostly because the effects here were unnecessary- the apple or the thought bubbles didn't make people laugh, that's for sure-, so if next week has more of them but they're funny, eh, I probably won't mind.
But I'd rather they weren't there. For the reasons you say.
I don't understand the complaints about the general use of graphics when this show has, for a long time, constantly used different elements from different genres, and constantly used elements that aren't 'normal'. My only problem was that there weren't really any bonuses to using them - unlike Jeff's heart last week, where you got things like Annie's boobs as at least a side joke, this week we had an apple retelling a joke that already existed and also, spelling things out way to much (we get its his 'ego apple', it doesn't need to say 'EGO' in big letters)
I enjoyed this episode. I thought it was better than last week's, at least.
I enjoyed this episode. I thought it was better than last week's, at least.
roosters93
Member
I thought of that, but not sure.
faceless007
Member
That episode was....
...
...what the fuck was that?
...
...what the fuck was that?
PhoncipleBone
Banned
Wow. Season 3 (in HD!) is available for $19.99 for the whole season on iTunes right now.
Insane price to get episodes in HD the day after they air. I have not checked to see if other legit sources are that cheap right now.
Insane price to get episodes in HD the day after they air. I have not checked to see if other legit sources are that cheap right now.
Loved the episode. I understand thinking plenty of it was silly; the actual scene of Jeff's freakout and Chang's tag scene were a little ridiculous. But dammit if the entire episode wasn't hysterical. Moby impersonator, high buttcrack, both michael jacksons, fat brando/burt reynolds/fat burt, using an apple to demonstrate, hothothot, and more. It was hysterical.
The Jeff plot had a nice small bit of character work to it, even if it didn't grow him out as much as I would have liked. But it's still impossible to knock what he learned tonight as being negligible: Jeff learned that he's still very much a work in progress, and his problems are only beginning to be confronted.
And of course, Troy and Abed. That was so good. The perfect balance of self-reflexivity, unique situation, and universal emotion. Simply amazing.
The Jeff plot had a nice small bit of character work to it, even if it didn't grow him out as much as I would have liked. But it's still impossible to knock what he learned tonight as being negligible: Jeff learned that he's still very much a work in progress, and his problems are only beginning to be confronted.
And of course, Troy and Abed. That was so good. The perfect balance of self-reflexivity, unique situation, and universal emotion. Simply amazing.
The Broken Ska Record
Member
I really liked today's episode, and had a smile on my face for most of it. I can see how people don't like the cartoony gags, and I do agree that used too often will kinda make the show a bit too "cartoony."
I can't help but compare this episode with the one in season 2 with the Inception parody. It was done subtly, and not heavy-handed and the stuff in the last few episodes. I liked the Chang setup, but I'm not sure how I'm going to like the Evil Abed stuff. I just hope there's a pay-off with that this season unlike Pierce's drug use last season.
I can't help but compare this episode with the one in season 2 with the Inception parody. It was done subtly, and not heavy-handed and the stuff in the last few episodes. I liked the Chang setup, but I'm not sure how I'm going to like the Evil Abed stuff. I just hope there's a pay-off with that this season unlike Pierce's drug use last season.
Baconsammy
Banned
It's been at that price on iTunes and XBL for over a week now. Seasons 1 and 2 on sale as well.
AlphaTwo00
Member
I've finally saw this morning. I enjoyed it. Pacing wise, it's a bit scattered, but that's kinda the issue with an ensemble cast that's not confined to the same room: people are split doing their own thing, and it becomes harder and harder to keep track of everyone.
But yeah, shit got dark.
And as for the visual gags: really? I get the complaint about having it two episodes in a row back to back, but somehow these are bad and the anime one is ok? Just seems like a wonky double standard that apparently Community can't go lowbrow route. It's been a series that's more than willing to do stupid things just for the sake of them (announcing a bottle episode, in the bottle episode?), so why not cheap visual gags to setup?
The other thing that may actually be happening, if you've seen the S2 dvd's, is possibly budget concerns: since these weren't airing right away, they were able to plan out how to allocate their cost on the episodes, and these ones may be done "on the cheap" (like the bottle episode) just to keep things in line.
But yeah, shit got dark.
And as for the visual gags: really? I get the complaint about having it two episodes in a row back to back, but somehow these are bad and the anime one is ok? Just seems like a wonky double standard that apparently Community can't go lowbrow route. It's been a series that's more than willing to do stupid things just for the sake of them (announcing a bottle episode, in the bottle episode?), so why not cheap visual gags to setup?
The other thing that may actually be happening, if you've seen the S2 dvd's, is possibly budget concerns: since these weren't airing right away, they were able to plan out how to allocate their cost on the episodes, and these ones may be done "on the cheap" (like the bottle episode) just to keep things in line.
Baconsammy
Banned
Need gifs of Troy dancing as Jackson and Britta moonwalking. The Troy gif would be the perfect reaction shot to any good news.
ipitydatfu
Member
i love it
Shorty11857
Member
Ratings dropped back down to a 1.7...
Baconsammy
Banned
i love it
That's the good shit right there!
...and it was the highest-rated show on NBC which, in my mind, combines with nearing syndication prospects to solidify its position ahead of Up All Night and even 30 Rock. Meaning it'll probably be renewed.
EDIT: And even thinking about how some people are saying "we'll see when BBT gets back," I don't think it matters. If BBT and Community have such overlap that one being gone boosts the ratings of the other, doesn't that mean Community would be even more favored for renewal? Because it sharing viewers in that way means it's at least worthy of fighting against BBT. A new show might not split the audience any.
Hot Coldman
Banned
1.7? Still tight enough.
Her reaction shot when Jeff ripped his shirt off was enough for me.
Her reaction shot when Jeff ripped his shirt off was enough for me.
Baconsammy
Banned
She had a similar reaction early in the episode. Two of my favorite moments in the show. I love Horny Annie.
MiniBossBattle
Member
What does it mean that I find Britta attractive, even in late MJ form?
It means you have pretty good taste in women.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
I think the visual effects were a nod to Troy's monologue on reality.
Nappuccino
Member
I don't think the idea of the graphics was that bad. But Chang's could have used some fine-tuning and we probably only needed to see Jeff's Apple Ego once: when it exploded.
Baconsammy
Banned
The scene doesn't last long enough to be a good gif, unless I'm missing another one where she moonwalks.
It's good for threads that have gone to hell and you just wanna back the heck out.
So basically, it's good for GAF.
She and Britta were sharing the same story, just with different people.
Annie is worried about Abed, Britta with Jeff. Britta got this weeks spotlight, I'm sure Annie will get more as the Abed/Troy/Annie situation develops.
Baconsammy
Banned
Hot Coldman
Banned
Oh snap, I just realised something. Putting this in spoilers, because although it's speculation, it's probably right. Also, it concerns a future episode we already know about.
The Dreamatorium episode... Annie's going to have to fight Evil Abed, isn't she?
Mystic Theurge
Member
I think this episode was much better than last week's. Funny and lots of juicy foreshadowing.
Not a very good ep to me, probably worse than last weeks. Didn't really like anything except Troy and Abed having a disagreement and having to figure that out.
One of my favorite parts of the series was Troy's birthday and him driving everyone home and you kind of see him growing into a leadership role, or at least more of a man. I like how this is slowly kind of coming into conflict with Abed's childlike ways. And you saw a bit of that this week. The whole dark abed thing really sullied it though and i hope that was just supposed to be a funny one off.
Yeah on the whole the ep just was not funny. The whole impersonation thing was just a big one-off, i thought they really could have gotten more mileage out of everybodys characters but it's like they just expected you to laugh at them dressing up. Jeff's whole anxiety thing was poorly acted, he didn't seem hugely different from normal and it was just a poor plot. Changs plot was also pretty bad, waaay too cartoonish with the thought bubbles.
I think less Chang is better, they did get me with that shooting of the window that was pretty good, but his character has kind of changed for the worse. I think it was better when he was just "crazy college teacher". You didn't know much about him you just saw all these weird and off-beat things he did and he was rarely the focus of the subplots. He would just be in the background.
One of my favorite parts of the series was Troy's birthday and him driving everyone home and you kind of see him growing into a leadership role, or at least more of a man. I like how this is slowly kind of coming into conflict with Abed's childlike ways. And you saw a bit of that this week. The whole dark abed thing really sullied it though and i hope that was just supposed to be a funny one off.
Yeah on the whole the ep just was not funny. The whole impersonation thing was just a big one-off, i thought they really could have gotten more mileage out of everybodys characters but it's like they just expected you to laugh at them dressing up. Jeff's whole anxiety thing was poorly acted, he didn't seem hugely different from normal and it was just a poor plot. Changs plot was also pretty bad, waaay too cartoonish with the thought bubbles.
I think less Chang is better, they did get me with that shooting of the window that was pretty good, but his character has kind of changed for the worse. I think it was better when he was just "crazy college teacher". You didn't know much about him you just saw all these weird and off-beat things he did and he was rarely the focus of the subplots. He would just be in the background.
Sketch_Turntable
Member
aparisi2274
Member
Not sure if this was discussed, but should this episode have aired last week?
In the beginning of last nights episode, they are all just coming back from New Years break, so then when would last weeks episode have taken place in the community timeline?
In the beginning of last nights episode, they are all just coming back from New Years break, so then when would last weeks episode have taken place in the community timeline?
Scalemail Ted
Member
This is genius... This is how the seasons arc must go... It just seems so well seeded with remedial chaos theory.
Anyone else think this was a homage to the scene in Terminator 2 where Linda Hamilton first encounters T800, thinking he's back to kill her? Can't find any pictures of it, but that's the first thing I thought of.Need Dean reaction to Jeff in his aviators more.
NM! We already have it.
Also love that Stamos doesn't dig the graphics used in the last two episodes. Maybe there's a chance they can be quickly edited out before they air?
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked