See, I'm kind of more suspicious of Trigger than yesterday. Beyond what I already said about agreeing with Kark's theory, I feel like if any of the prominent lynch candidates had been scum, me voting for Trigger would have caused some increase in traction in that direction, in order to push somewhere else. But it didn't happen, and I wonder why. Kark's argument sounded good to me so I wonder why it + my vote didn't sound good to anyone else.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Batman [Mafia] |OT| The mafia game Gafia deserves , but not the one it needs
- Thread starter roytheone
- Start date
So basically, you are sitting on Trigger the same way I am sitting on Karu. The current vote is a great mislynch, scum doesn't want to rock the boat away from it.
weemadarthur
Member
If Mazre flips scum, this is worth considering. But if Mazre flips town, then the scum team is just waiting because they don't need to do anything, and we look at the latter votes on mazre. The whole team probably won't be there, but some.
coppanuva (0)
sorian 907 (1024)
fireblend 1440 (1575)
sorian 1459 (1752)
camjo-z (4)
launchpadmcq 909 (1247)
mazre 1535 (1810)
karkador 1605
xamtheking 1640 (1784)
coppanuva 1763
xamtheking 1787 (1896)
absolutbro 1895
ty4on 1897
fluxwavez (0)
fireblend 914 (1440)
xamtheking 1101 (1493)
weemadarthur 1160 (1229)
trigger 1171 (1254)
pop-o-matic (1)
fluxwavez 917
karu (1)
sorian 1024 (1232)
sorian 1752
mazre 1810 (1866)
karkador (0)
sorian 1232 (1329)
camjo-z 1259 (1392)
tl21xx 1261 (1563)
sorian (2)
karkador 1246 (1509)
launchpadmcq 1247 (1453)
pop-o-matic 1808
mazre 1866
mazre (6)
weemadarthur 1307
trigger 1327
xamtheking 1493 (1640)
ty4on 1558 (1897)
tl21xx 1581
karu 1609
launchpadmcq 1746
xamtheking 1784 (1787)
xamtheking 1896
tl21xx (0)
sorian 1329 (1329)
sorian 1451 (1459)
ty4on (0)
sorian 1329 (1451)
launchpadmcq (1)
camjo-z 1392
xamtheking (0)
launchpadmcq 1453 (1722)
trigger (1)
karkador 1509 (1605)
fireblend 1575
fireblend (1)
el topo
camjo-z (4)
karkador 1605
coppanuva 1763
absolutbro 1895
ty4on 1897
fluxwavez (0)
pop-o-matic (1)
fluxwavez 917
karu (1)
sorian 1752
karkador (0)
sorian (2)
pop-o-matic 1808
mazre 1866
mazre (6)
weemadarthur 1307
trigger 1327
tl21xx 1581
karu 1609
launchpadmcq 1746
xamtheking 1896
tl21xx (0)
ty4on (0)
launchpadmcq (1)
camjo-z 1392
xamtheking (0)
trigger (1)
fireblend 1575
fireblend (1)
el topo
Xamtheking
Member
Sorian can you please give us a cushion now
You are really worried about controlling my vote. I'm only one person and I'm here staring at the computer for the next 19 minutes anyway. If my vote is needed that it can be used, if not then I'm sticking to my guns, I think this lynch is stupid and I think the second place is even stupider.
Camjo has you now anyway.
Xamtheking
Member
thanks jason
I pressed x
I pressed x
AbsolutBro
Member
Not that it really matters Roy, but you have Fluxwavez's vote counting on Pop after I replaced him.
I know, but I am on mobile right now and editing that out constantly is way too hard
Can it run arkham Knight stutter free?
Not even batman has that technology.
Pop-O-Matic
Banned
Yeah, can't really add much to the discussion right now. Mazre's gonna die and I don't have much of a problem with that. I just think there's a couple of better options...
Pop-O-Matic
Banned
Still more fun than Dawn of Justice
weemadarthur
Member
This does seem too quiet.
But I'm serious about removing inactives, and that's where mafia commonly hide. Hopefully this will at least make everyone participate meaningfully if Mazre is town.
But I'm serious about removing inactives, and that's where mafia commonly hide. Hopefully this will at least make everyone participate meaningfully if Mazre is town.
Please don't
Swipe writing is the worst invention ever
Final thoughts for the day just so there is something here if I die.
Town: Still weemad and Fire
Cleared via use of power, worth revisiting if he lives on a night he should have died: Camjo
Scummy but has claimed in such a way where pursuit seems sub-optimal: Xam and Kark
Scummy: Karu, Coppa, TL21xx
Added TL21xx, been going back and forth on him but his inactivity doesn't sit right with me. I don't think he is lying about real life stuff at all and that's not what it is. The overly slow game is a just a point of interest to me. Definitely a fringe case but I've been doing a top 3 for awhile now so I wanted one more on there (it's not in any order though).
Town: Still weemad and Fire
Cleared via use of power, worth revisiting if he lives on a night he should have died: Camjo
Scummy but has claimed in such a way where pursuit seems sub-optimal: Xam and Kark
Scummy: Karu, Coppa, TL21xx
Added TL21xx, been going back and forth on him but his inactivity doesn't sit right with me. I don't think he is lying about real life stuff at all and that's not what it is. The overly slow game is a just a point of interest to me. Definitely a fringe case but I've been doing a top 3 for awhile now so I wanted one more on there (it's not in any order though).
Pop-O-Matic
Banned
Here's hoping the flip/EoD Flavor doesn't take forever again...
Final vote count for day 2:
coppanuva (0)
sorian 907 (1024)
fireblend 1440 (1575)
sorian 1459 (1752)
camjo-z (4)
launchpadmcq 909 (1247)
mazre 1535 (1810)
karkador 1605
xamtheking 1640 (1784)
coppanuva 1763
xamtheking 1787 (1896)
absolutbro 1895
ty4on 1897
fluxwavez (0)
fireblend 914 (1440)
xamtheking 1101 (1493)
weemadarthur 1160 (1229)
trigger 1171 (1254)
pop-o-matic (0)
fluxwavez 917
karu (1)
sorian 1024 (1232)
sorian 1752
mazre 1810 (1866)
karkador (0)
sorian 1232 (1329)
camjo-z 1259 (1392)
tl21xx 1261 (1563)
sorian (2)
karkador 1246 (1509)
launchpadmcq 1247 (1453)
pop-o-matic 1808
mazre 1866
mazre (7)
weemadarthur 1307
trigger 1327
xamtheking 1493 (1640)
ty4on 1558 (1897)
tl21xx 1581
karu 1609
launchpadmcq 1746
xamtheking 1784 (1787)
xamtheking 1896
camjo-z 1911
tl21xx (0)
sorian 1329 (1329)
sorian 1451 (1459)
ty4on (0)
sorian 1329 (1451)
launchpadmcq (0)
camjo-z 1392 (1911)
xamtheking (0)
launchpadmcq 1453 (1722)
trigger (1)
karkador 1509 (1605)
fireblend 1575
fireblend (1)
el topo 1874
coppanuva (0)
camjo-z (4)
karkador 1605
coppanuva 1763
absolutbro 1895
ty4on 1897
fluxwavez (0)
pop-o-matic (0)
karu (1)
sorian 1752
karkador (0)
sorian (2)
pop-o-matic 1808
mazre 1866
mazre (7)
weemadarthur 1307
trigger 1327
tl21xx 1581
karu 1609
launchpadmcq 1746
xamtheking 1896
camjo-z 1911
tl21xx (0)
ty4on (0)
launchpadmcq (0)
xamtheking (0)
trigger (1)
fireblend 1575
fireblend (1)
el topo 1874
After an uneasy night, they woke up. Still shocked from the terrifying happenings of the previous day.
"Man, that was something yesterday, have you guys ever seen something that horrible?"
"No, that was the most disgusting thing I have ever seen in my life!"
"Yeah, how is it possible that such a horrendous movie exists!"
"Indeed"
"Oh yeah, I guess Mazre exploding was kinda bad too, but hot damn is Batman & Robin terrible! "
From his control room, The Riddler looked at them with disgust
"If you guys are done chitchatting, would you be so kind to look around the room? I don't know why I am surprised, but apparently you idiots CAN'T COUNT!"
Just like yesterday, it didn't took long for them to find the body. There lay TL21xx. His body filled with bullet holes. His glasses lay broken beside his body. His impressive moustache red of blood.
Everyone was shocked.
Everyone?
TL21xx has died!
Day 3 begins
14 people are still alive! 8 votes are needed for majority!
Pop-O-Matic
Banned
Welp, might as well get us started. Still believe what I said yesterday, so...
Vote: Sorian
Vote: Sorian
Xamtheking
Member
Roy I think you need to settle down
Huh, town role cop, gafia usually reserves that as a scum power, wonder if that means we have a regular cop or not?
VOTE: LaunchpadMcQ
Not because I think you are scum but because I believe you promised us story time.
By regular cop, I mean alignment cop.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
Ok, time to spill the beans and hopefully we can catch some scum today.
Now, as for my role, I had to do a lot of grandstanding to play it up for several reasons.
1) I was in total control of the role. If I died, I wouldn't have received the results. I had to let scum believe that there was nothing that could stop it, including killing me.
2) If I revealed too much about the role, scum would probably have figured out what was going on and killed me.
3) Everything I said up until now has been true, except for a few half-truths and omissions.
I am Harvey Bullock. My ability is a sort of stakeout ability where I choose someone during the first night phase, watch someone over the day phase, and receive a message during the following night phase. This message tells me whether or not there were any non-town players who voted for this player.
My intended use of this ability was to get a small group of players to vote on Camjo and then try to either clear them or create a small pool where we can start scum-hunting; this is why I said that the ability may not prove useful in this day phase, because we may not figure out who the scum/neutral in the group is.
Now, the thing is, I received the message that there are one or more non-town players in the pool that voted for Camjo. Here's the thing; I asked for 3 players ideally. I thought this was a small enough pool that the probability of having a mafia in it was small. I was intending to clear 3 town players with this ability. I was trying to clear Kark, who I believe is town, and the others seemed towny to me. However, there was a straggler there...
Like, what? Who asked him to do this?
VOTE: Ty4on
Now, as for my role, I had to do a lot of grandstanding to play it up for several reasons.
1) I was in total control of the role. If I died, I wouldn't have received the results. I had to let scum believe that there was nothing that could stop it, including killing me.
2) If I revealed too much about the role, scum would probably have figured out what was going on and killed me.
3) Everything I said up until now has been true, except for a few half-truths and omissions.
I am Harvey Bullock. My ability is a sort of stakeout ability where I choose someone during the first night phase, watch someone over the day phase, and receive a message during the following night phase. This message tells me whether or not there were any non-town players who voted for this player.
My intended use of this ability was to get a small group of players to vote on Camjo and then try to either clear them or create a small pool where we can start scum-hunting; this is why I said that the ability may not prove useful in this day phase, because we may not figure out who the scum/neutral in the group is.
Now, the thing is, I received the message that there are one or more non-town players in the pool that voted for Camjo. Here's the thing; I asked for 3 players ideally. I thought this was a small enough pool that the probability of having a mafia in it was small. I was intending to clear 3 town players with this ability. I was trying to clear Kark, who I believe is town, and the others seemed towny to me. However, there was a straggler there...
Like, what? Who asked him to do this?
VOTE: Ty4on
Xamtheking
Member
Ah ok
That makes sense why you wouldn't tell us
Obviously
That makes sense why you wouldn't tell us
Obviously
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
tl;dr
There is scum/neutral in this group of players:
karkador
coppanuva
absolutbro
ty4on
Day end.
There is scum/neutral in this group of players:
karkador
coppanuva
absolutbro
ty4on
Day end.
So you are claiming there is non-town within: Kark, Coppa, Absolut, and Ty4on?
Golly gee, I wonder which lead I want to chase today? Oh I know, the same drum I've been smacking since day fucking 1.
VOTE: Coppanuva
And not even because I believe Launch completely because this could still all be grand standing from a scum making up a, admittingly, very grandiose claim but because now there is a potentially smaller list that still has someone I am skeptical of on it.
Golly gee, I wonder which lead I want to chase today? Oh I know, the same drum I've been smacking since day fucking 1.
VOTE: Coppanuva
And not even because I believe Launch completely because this could still all be grand standing from a scum making up a, admittingly, very grandiose claim but because now there is a potentially smaller list that still has someone I am skeptical of on it.
Xamtheking
Member
Karkerdore is probably not scum
Absolutbro probably not scum going off of flux's behavior
Coppa and ty4on have been non-entities
Absolutbro probably not scum going off of flux's behavior
Coppa and ty4on have been non-entities
I need to not forget that Absolut replaced Flux. That whole thread fell away when he asked for a replacement and PW should have taught you all that scum is just as likely to search out a replacement as town.
Xam, who were you on last night?
Xamtheking
Member
Karkerdoodledoo
I was on you for a good portion of the day
But I changed because I realized scum might target Kark because he was in the Camjo vote
Also, QB was acting much different than Flux was
Meh, expected choice so nothing to really call you on if I don't think you are the doctor aside from the obvious "why are you still alive?" bait. Skip.
Drago as well in PW but Flux was acting sketchy no matter how you slice it, the type of sketchy doesn't suddenly make it better.
Xamtheking
Member
Dick Grayson