• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NHL '12 Playoffs |OT| "The Cup is our destiny this year."

MacAttack

Member
With each ruling the NHL makes I just am more and more flabbergasted.

There is no rhyme or reason to anything they're doing. It's like they're just drawing the guy's name out of a hat and then spinning a wheel-of-fortune like wheel with random fines and games on it.
The Carkner - Hagelin suspensions shouldn't be that surprising. Injuries are a part of the disciplinary process and have been all season. What Carkner did was stupid but Boyle was much less vulnerable to injury than Alfredsson regardless of intent. The league has come down pretty hard on high hits all season. See Byron Bitz for a comparable high hit and resulting discipline.
 

Socreges

Banned
Domination 5-on-5.... produces nothing. We're going to lose another fucking game due to shitty special teams, I know it.

You said it was "common sense" he got the misconduct. That only makes sense if you accept the premise that one set of rules is absolutely preferable to the other.
Common sense being that 'late hits that target the head' = BAD.
 
Karlsson was engaged with him as a willing participant in a scrum, and Boyle's gloves didn't even come off in that exchange. He's not blameless by any means, but the orders of magnitude between what Boyle did to Karlsson and what Carkner did to Boyle are RIDICULOUS.

Willing participant ? Really now ? A 5'11 D-man is willingly going to fight a player who's 6'7 ?
 

Cake Boss

Banned
Karlsson was engaged with him as a willing participant in a scrum, and Boyle's gloves didn't even come off in that exchange. He's not blameless by any means, but the orders of magnitude between what Boyle did to Karlsson and what Carkner did to Boyle are RIDICULOUS.

WTF please stop posting.

Yeah that Karlsson is always a willing participant in scrums, especially against a 6'7 players. Yeah that Karlsson really wanted a piece of Boyle, thats what hes know for.
 

ShaneB

Member
Rangers coming out with a statement about the leagues inconsistency with discipline. Can't blame them, and I doubt it'll be the last here this post season.
 

Plinko

Wildcard berths that can't beat teams without a winning record should have homefield advantage
The Carkner - Hagelin suspensions shouldn't be that surprising. Injuries are a part of the disciplinary process and have been all season. What Carkner did was stupid but Boyle was much less vulnerable to injury than Alfredsson regardless of intent. The league has come down pretty hard on high hits all season. See Byron Bitz for a comparable high hit and resulting discipline.

Carkner basically assaulted a guy from behind.
 

Plinko

Wildcard berths that can't beat teams without a winning record should have homefield advantage
Rangers coming out with a statement about the leagues inconsistency with discipline. Can't blame them, and I doubt it'll be the last here this post season.

Good for them.

I look forward to Philly's statement tomorrow night.
 

Ether_Snake

安安安安安安安安安安安安安安安
Shanahan needs to GTFO. Bettman should fire him.

Shanahan is too young, this guy still has close links to players in the league, he is inconsistent, he's an idiot. Can't believe all these hits in these playoffs, it wasn't that bad last year.
 

Socreges

Banned
And if you watched older hockey you'd realize that is a gross oversimplification. That's the point.
ibnjijIUq7N0p6.gif


Make your arguments, whatever they are. But enough with resorting to the meaningless 'you don't know old hockey like I do' stuff.
 
Shanahan needs to GTFO. Bettman should fire him.

Shanahan is too young, this guy still has close links to players in the league, he is inconsistent, he's an idiot. Can't believe all these hits in these playoffs, it wasn't that bad last year.

Shanahan was suspending people a lot in the preseason until GMs and NHLPA whined.
Doesn't matter who's in charge of suspensions.
 

Smiley90

Stop shitting on my team. Start shitting on my finger.
Penner gets a penalty for... uhm... uhm... yeah...

EDIT: Well, good thing Penner's out.
 
So proud of Weiss tonight, he was physical, dominated the face-offs and worked on D too. Campbell also stepped up and worked like horse in both ends.

Great game by the Cats.
 
Top Bottom