Support NeoGAF

[CCS]

I don't really want to ask you questions because you have the glorious luxury of being able to have a genuinely untainted perspective, but in the event that there are better lynches than Ouro, you really need to be arguing for them. Being an Innocent Child and trying to go with a policy lynch is a godawful idea. If you go through a particular line of reasoning and come to a particular conclusion, we know it is genuine. If you just lynch on policy, one of the few opportunities we have for that genuine reasoning is just gone. Anyone can policy - that's why they call it policy. You don't have much time left and you really need to be making a positive case.

Sorry, I was being low effort because I was playing Skyrim

So of my four lynchees I'd be happy with:

Squidy, my policy lynch.

You. You haven't been particularly scummier than several others, but you're too dangerous to be left alive if I think you could be scum

LP. Also low activity, and knowing scum/town would be very interesting for analysing the early pile on on him.

Kyan. Fairly low contribution/post ratio. Plays a bit like me in that regard, but doesn't have the excuse of being a child

If I had to lead a non-policy, non-ouro lynch, it would be you or LP.

UNVOTE

 

[Deleted member 231381]

The worst part is you didn't even get a scum win from that masterpiece of fake town theater.

And you blew any trust any town will ever have in you.

Given how that setup worked, I got a moral scum win.

 

[YesNOnoNOYes]

CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Ourobolus (4)
Lone_Prodigy #69 #165
CzarTim #106 #169
Haly #115 #202
Crab #423
Timeaisis #493
squidyj #532
Haly #536

Timeaisis (3)
Ourobolus #215 #504
CCS #310 #379
Kyanrute #491
Ourobolus #504
Kawl_USC #543

Lone_Prodigy (1)
CzarTim #169 #442
Haly #202 #536
Crab #222 #423
batsnacks #260 #343
Kawl_USC #323 #347
melonrabbit #409

Crab (1)
melonrabbit #137 #237
Kawl_USC #373 #543
batsnacks #375 #441
CzarTim #442

batsnacks (1)
Gorlak #57
Timeaisis #82 #200

melonrabbit (1)
Kawl_USC #132 #175
Lone_Prodigy #395

Gorlak (0): Ourobolus #60 #215, batsnacks #63 #260, Kawl_USC #175 #323, Timeaisis #200 #493

CzarTim (0): Kawl_USC #347 #373

Kyanrute (0): squidyj #259 #532

Kawl_USC (0): melonrabbit #109 #111

squidyj (0): Haly #58 #115, CCS #413 #551

CCS (0): Kawl_USC #90 #132

No active vote for Day 1: batsnacks (has previously voted), CCS (has previously voted)


Day 1 ends:

Automated vote tally here

Plurality Lynch

 

[batsnacks]

my advise

Squidy, my policy lynch.

eh

You. You haven't been particularly scummier than several others, but you're too dangerous to be left alive if I think you could be scum

most people are town most of the time, don't lynch someone for this.

LP. Also low activity, and knowing scum/town would be very interesting for analysing the early pile on on him.

that one's okay

 

[CCS]

VOTE: Crab

Dominus Illuminatio Mea.

 

[melonrabbit]

So Ouro or Time?

I'd go Time before Ouro, but don't really get scum vibes from either at the moment.

 

[squidyj]

Sorry, I was being low effort because I was playing Skyrim

So of my four lynchees I'd be happy with:

Squidy, my policy lynch.

You. You haven't been particularly scummier than several others, but you're too dangerous to be left alive if I think you could be scum

LP. Also low activity, and knowing scum/town would be very interesting for analysing the early pile on on him.

Kyan. Fairly low contribution/post ratio. Plays a bit like me in that regard, but doesn't have the excuse of being a child

If I had to lead a non-policy, non-ouro lynch, it would be you or LP.

UNVOTE

I agree. we should lynch Kyan.

 

[Ourobolus]

VOTE: Crab

Dominus Illuminatio Mea.

Pick a side

 

[CCS]

If it is going to be Ouro v Time...

So I actually was suspecting Time earlier when he was quieter, but as he's posted more I've become happier.

And I can't help but feel that we might keep coming back to Ouro if he survives.

I don't really want to lynch either though. I'll stick where I am for now.

 

[Kawl_USC]

Naw we can make crab the other side. I'm diggity down with that.

Vote: crab

 

[melonrabbit]

Despite the fact he is has disappeared once again and added nothing to the discussion the LP lynch is looking unlikely. Definitely want to revisit this tomorrow.

unvote

 

[Kawl_USC]

Ouro 4
Crab 3
Time 2 by my count.

Stand and be counted

 

[Gorlak]

bats ain't an option for y'all?

lp is forgotten about because he stays silent at day end?

cool



ouro/timeaisis/crab
hmm

 

[Deleted member 231381]

VOTE: Crab

Dominus Illuminatio Mea.

but why.

Your only reasoning is that I'm a good player. I'm also a good player as town, and more often than not, I'll draw town, because that's how maths works. So odds are (and the case is), you're making things worse for town.

There's too many people with some kind of weird stick-up for me because of one game from 3 seasons ago. Exactly this same thing (oh Crab was good in HP I'll throw votes on Crab for no reason) just made me disenthused in PopMafia and that went terribly for town. It's just not worth my time.

I've given you a really strong case for why Ouro is scum. Even now, Ouro is coasting. Read his most recent posts. There's nothing there. Nothing.

 

[Ourobolus]

I've given you a really strong case for why Ouro is scum. Even now, Ouro is coasting. Read his most recent posts. There's nothing there. Nothing.

nah.

Vote: Crab

I'd rather it be Time, but if I have to tie it up, then here I go.

 

[melonrabbit]

bats ain't an option for y'all?

lp is forgotten about because he stays silent at day end?

cool



ouro/timeaisis/crab
hmm

Hey you guys weren't interested in LP. He is at the top of my list.

 

[batsnacks]

why's Crab mafia?

 

[CCS]

but why.

Your only reasoning is that I'm a good player. I'm also a good player as town, and more often than not, I'll draw town, because that's how maths works. So odds are (and the case is), you're making things worse for town.

There's too many people with some kind of weird stick-up for me because of one game from 3 seasons ago. Exactly this same thing (oh Crab was good in HP I'll throw votes on Crab for no reason) just made me disenthused in PopMafia and that went terribly for town. It's just not worth my time.

I've given you a really strong case for why Ouro is scum. Even now, Ouro is coasting. Read his most recent posts. There's nothing there. Nothing.

Fair enough.

Vote: Ourobolus

That's staying unless Ouro actually puts up a decent defence.

 

[Ourobolus]

do we wanna get a train going on LP? I'm down.

 

[Deleted member 231381]

do we wanna get a train going on LP? I'm down.

I'm not opposed to it. But I want a really good explanation from you for why.

 

[Gorlak]

not voting ouro today

time gave kind of no impression to me. he seemed to follow people rather than act on his own, but who am I to say that's his scummy appearance or not?

I see no reason to lynch crab today

 

[Ourobolus]

I'm not opposed to it. But I want a really good explanation from you for why.

He's scummy.

Also I'd prefer to not be lynched.

 

[YesNOnoNOYes]

CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Ourobolus (5)
Lone_Prodigy #69 #165
CzarTim #106 #169
Haly #115 #202
Crab #423
Timeaisis #493
squidyj #532
Haly #536
CCS #568

Crab (3)
melonrabbit #137 #237
Kawl_USC #373 #543
batsnacks #375 #441
CzarTim #442
CCS #555 #568
Kawl_USC #560
Ourobolus #565

batsnacks (1)
Gorlak #57
Timeaisis #82 #200

Timeaisis (1)
Ourobolus #215 #504
CCS #310 #379
Kyanrute #491
Ourobolus #504 #565
Kawl_USC #543 #560

melonrabbit (1)
Kawl_USC #132 #175
Lone_Prodigy #395

CCS (0): Kawl_USC #90 #132

Kyanrute (0): squidyj #259 #532

Kawl_USC (0): melonrabbit #109 #111

squidyj (0): Haly #58 #115, CCS #413 #551

CzarTim (0): Kawl_USC #347 #373

Gorlak (0): Ourobolus #60 #215, batsnacks #63 #260, Kawl_USC #175 #323, Timeaisis #200 #493

Lone_Prodigy (0): CzarTim #169 #442, Haly #202 #536, Crab #222 #423, batsnacks #260 #343, Kawl_USC #323 #347, melonrabbit #409 #561

No active vote for Day 1: batsnacks (has previously voted), melonrabbit (has previously voted)


Day 1 ends:

Automated vote tally here

Plurality Lynch

 

[Deleted member 231381]

He's scummy.

Also I'd prefer to not be lynched.

eh fuck it.

I'm game if you are.

VOTE: Lone_Prodigy

 

[Ourobolus]

Here I'll get us started.

Vote: Lone_Prodigy

 

[Ourobolus]

dammit crab

 

[Kawl_USC]

eh fuck it.

I'm game if you are.

VOTE: Lone_Prodigy

That's what constitutes a really good argument nowadays?

 

[Gorlak]

He's scummy.

Also I'd prefer to not be lynched.

What's that with you? Usually you prefer to get some info out of D1 and draw the nightkill to yourself. Right now you give the impression of being totally reluctant to even play this game.

 

[Ourobolus]

What's that with you? Usually you prefer to get some info out of D1 and draw the nightkill to yourself. Right now you give the impression of being totally reluctant to even play this game.

D1 is useful to me on D2

 

[Deleted member 231381]

hah no u won't

slowpoke ouro is slowpoke

 

[YesNOnoNOYes]

CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Ourobolus (4)
Lone_Prodigy #69 #165
CzarTim #106 #169
Haly #115 #202
Crab #423 #574
Timeaisis #493
squidyj #532
Haly #536
CCS #568

Crab (2)
melonrabbit #137 #237
Kawl_USC #373 #543
batsnacks #375 #441
CzarTim #442
CCS #555 #568
Kawl_USC #560
Ourobolus #565 #575

Lone_Prodigy (2)
CzarTim #169 #442
Haly #202 #536
Crab #222 #423
batsnacks #260 #343
Kawl_USC #323 #347
melonrabbit #409 #561
Crab #574
Ourobolus #575

batsnacks (1)
Gorlak #57
Timeaisis #82 #200

Timeaisis (1)
Ourobolus #215 #504
CCS #310 #379
Kyanrute #491
Ourobolus #504 #565
Kawl_USC #543 #560

melonrabbit (1)
Kawl_USC #132 #175
Lone_Prodigy #395

Kawl_USC (0): melonrabbit #109 #111

CzarTim (0): Kawl_USC #347 #373

Kyanrute (0): squidyj #259 #532

CCS (0): Kawl_USC #90 #132

squidyj (0): Haly #58 #115, CCS #413 #551

Gorlak (0): Ourobolus #60 #215, batsnacks #63 #260, Kawl_USC #175 #323, Timeaisis #200 #493

No active vote for Day 1: batsnacks (has previously voted), melonrabbit (has previously voted)


Day 1 ends:

Automated vote tally here

Plurality Lynch

 

[CzarTim]

Good time to go eat where are we at?

 

[Deleted member 231381]

That's what constitutes a really good argument nowadays?

My argument against L_P was made way earlier today. I've not added anything as he has been completely absent since. It's still the same case.

 

[Ourobolus]

Good time to go eat where are we at?

Voting LP. Or Time.

 

[squidyj]

yeah uhhhh I've made myself pretty clear on LP.

 

[Kawl_USC]

My argument against L_P was made way earlier today. I've not added anything as he has been completely absent since. It's still the same case.

No I meant you were good with ouros argument there? You said that before getting on the LP wagon you wanted a really good argument from him. And you got...that. Which was enough?

 

[melonrabbit]

Really? Now we start this?

VOTE: Lone_Prodigy

 

[Ourobolus]

No I meant you were good with ouros argument there? You said that before getting on the LP wagon you wanted a really good argument from him. And you got...that. Which was enough?

gotta read the subtext

 

[CzarTim]

If I switch to lp Oreo is still in the lead. Anyone else switching?

 

[squidyj]

Voting LP. Or Time.

time has one vote. from kyan.
Yeahhh.............

 

[CCS]

I mean, I don't mind lynching LP, but I'm not convinced by ouro or Crab right now.

 

[YesNOnoNOYes]

CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

TEN MINUTES TO GO

Ourobolus (4)
Lone_Prodigy #69 #165
CzarTim #106 #169
Haly #115 #202
Crab #423 #574
Timeaisis #493
squidyj #532
Haly #536
CCS #568

Lone_Prodigy (3)
CzarTim #169 #442
Haly #202 #536
Crab #222 #423
batsnacks #260 #343
Kawl_USC #323 #347
melonrabbit #409 #561
Crab #574
Ourobolus #575
melonrabbit #587

Crab (2)
melonrabbit #137 #237
Kawl_USC #373 #543
batsnacks #375 #441
CzarTim #442
CCS #555 #568
Kawl_USC #560
Ourobolus #565 #575

melonrabbit (1)
Kawl_USC #132 #175
Lone_Prodigy #395

Timeaisis (1)
Ourobolus #215 #504
CCS #310 #379
Kyanrute #491
Ourobolus #504 #565
Kawl_USC #543 #560

batsnacks (1)
Gorlak #57
Timeaisis #82 #200

Gorlak (0): Ourobolus #60 #215, batsnacks #63 #260, Kawl_USC #175 #323, Timeaisis #200 #493

CzarTim (0): Kawl_USC #347 #373

Kyanrute (0): squidyj #259 #532

CCS (0): Kawl_USC #90 #132

squidyj (0): Haly #58 #115, CCS #413 #551

Kawl_USC (0): melonrabbit #109 #111

No active vote for Day 1: batsnacks (has previously voted)


Day 1 ends:

Automated vote tally here

Plurality Lynch

 

[Kawl_USC]

Fine play with my heart more ccs sigh

Vote: Lone_Prodigy

 

[Ourobolus]

time has one vote. from kyan.
Yeahhh.............

Well right, I moved mine. I'd still prefer him to go first but eh, what can you do

 

[CzarTim]

Ty Karl

Vote: Lone_Prodigy

 

[batsnacks]

lol

batsnacks (1)
Gorlak #57

 

[Kyanrute]

ok funfuns

VOTE: Lone_Prodigy

 

[Kawl_USC]

gotta read the subtext

Is that when you turn on the words at the bottom of a screen when you can't hear over the sound of the mastication of your TV dinner?

 

[squidyj]

Well right, I moved mine. I'd still prefer him to go first but eh, what can you do

I like it better than an LP lynch. which is what it looks like we're getting here.

 

[Lone_Prodigy]

Because no one asked, I voted melon because she's tunneling and bringing up Pixar, which is/was a different game. I can nitpick and choose previous games where someone was scum there too. Like, Mini 1?