• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Winter of Anime 2013 |OT -6| How much lower can we go?!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Regulus Tera

Romanes Eunt Domus
It was such a poorly constructed episode of television. Unless I'm vastly overestimating the Japanese girl's ability to follow stories anyway.

Beyond the nods at self-awareness (using science and technology), there are no consistent rules for the world, with tropes being the only thing that grounds the show into some cliche-ridden mess resembling a plot.
But... you stomached all of Smile's introductory episodes, and those are just as clichê-ridden, relying on even more common stereotypes. Episode four of DokiDoki works probably because it introduces a type of character not yet seen in this show. It's a genuine step forward from the boring Misses Perfectsies of Mana and whatsherface.
I don't think any of these characters are close to being human beings anyway, let alone interesting characters in a consistently constructed world.
Real talk: it sounds like you wanna watch Heartcatch.
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
But... you stomached all of Smile's introductory episodes, and those are just as clichê-ridden, relying on even more common stereotypes. Episode four of DokiDoki works probably because it introduces a type of character not yet seen in this show. It's a genuine step forward from the boring Misses Perfectsies of Mana and whatsherface.
Oh, I admit that the Smiles were all Mary Sues, but they weren't presented in such a stupid manner. I mean, this show isn't SAO level in terms of offending me, but I have felt insulted by each episode of Doki Doki so far.

In fact, it's almost like Akibaranger... but whereas Akibaranger was (loving) parody, Doki Doki wants me to take all of this stuff seriously.

Real talk: it sounds like you wanna watch Heartcatch.

I don't think I can do the two character thing after Smile. The whole cast needs to be together right from the start. lol
 

cajunator

Banned
Dental hygiene yo!

She's innocent and pure!

It was such a poorly constructed episode of television. Unless I'm vastly overestimating the Japanese girl's ability to follow stories anyway.

Beyond the nods at self-awareness (using science and technology), there are no consistent rules for the world, with tropes being the only thing that grounds the show into some cliche-ridden mess resembling a plot.

I don't think any of these characters are close to being human beings anyway, let alone interesting characters in a consistently constructed world.

Futari Wa Precure. Its good. The characters are like real people even!
 

RurouniZel

Asks questions so Ezalc doesn't have to
Choi killed anime.

e:

birth of a OTP:

79ohjen.png

I'm okay with this, but I prefer Tamako x Midori.
 
I think Incredibles and Ratatouille are both the best movies Pixar ever made. And will ever make.
So true . There is not even a contest here IMO.

Monsters INC is a close 3rd.

Rinne No Lagrange 8
Hey wait a minute. Is this show about lesbians?
It's a show about relationships .
The yuri is a bonus.

Gintama 183


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=usjwNp3s94c
ibbfyD8Cm3HO0E.gif
ibbfyD8Cm3HO0E.gif
ibbfyD8Cm3HO0E.gif
ibbfyD8Cm3HO0E.gif


Masterful. I am not worthy!
That's why we should lobby to make gintama mandatory in public school . or at least mandatory in animegaf.

Yu-Gi-Oh! ZeXal 04
There's the difference between pride in your own skill and just arrogance in believing that you know better than a mysterious floating spirit that only you can see and hear that you know better in dueling than he does. The main character is being all kinds of stupid and irritating.

And, does no one in this show know how to play the game? I mean really? You gotta ask about continuous magic cards? You guys even duel at school. I mean what the hell.
Ah ah ah Oh lol.

Yeah you're right .. they are really starting low . You bet next episode you'll have a lecture on counter traps ..
The only thing that need an explanationto newcommers should be the resolving states and priorities.

[Dokidoki! Precure] 04

An ojousama with nigh infinite resources? A butler who doubles as a spy around the city? A tragic backstory? A transformation sequence which is obviously on a higher tier than that of the rest of the characters? Cure Rosetta might as well be the goddamn Batman.

Yellow Precure bias aside, that was one of the best Precure introduction episodes I've seen. You usually don't want to waste too much time on dumb kid-oriented drama, but they managed to make Rosetta sufficiently self-aware for it to work. This aspect was even carried to the Selfishes of the week, with the writers skipping the dumb NPC monologuing and going straight for the action.
Ghetto-speaking Selfish was hilarious
. Gimme more of that, please!

Rankings: Rosetta > Sword > Diamond >>>>>>>>>>>> Heart

So it's getting better ?Glad to know that . I still plan to start doki doki once Ep 5 is aired to see if this show is worthy or not ...
 

Jintor

Member
Jackie Chan no Booken 12

Man, I wish American animation that wasn't airbender could get some sakuga to spare for finales. Ah well. That was a fun evening.
 

NeonZ

Member
Given that I've only finished one show out of the four I know about, is it just me when I say this is the worst Precure ever and is singlehandedly killing any interest I have in the franchise? It's burning all the goodwill I had as a Smile Precure fan.

It just seems like everyone is just "okay" with what they're being given... it's like people who defended Star Trek: Enterprise just because they've been fans of Star Trek for 20 years. :p

Many Pretty Cure fans in other forums seem to be enjoying how this series is focusing on characters backstories and such straight from the beginning and actually has competent characters (which apparent was a gripe of many about Smile's cast). I'm kind of on the same boat as you though, so far Doki Doki has just bored me. The childish drama without heavy contrast with humor just isn't working for me right now. I mean, Smile's drama also was childish, but it helped that it was usually accompained by the few moments of great action in the series and was surrounded by light hearted humor everywhere else.

I also feel like the animation of transformations and attacks really lacks impact here. You'd have to go back to Pretty Cure 5 to see something as bland as these.
 

Cwarrior

Member

Back when I played this game I had to clue what moe even meant, I never got the joke when the trailer came out on gaf(first time hearing of it) or when playing the game.

Only found out what moe even was in 2011(maybe late 2010), dissipate having watched anime for 2 decades.

I knew it had something to do with pedophilia and anime.
 

Seraphis Cain

bad gameplay lol
Great game.
Love the Bizarre Jelly 5 characters too.

I'm playing through Heroes' Paradise right now (which will be my second time through the game), and it's really nowhere near as bad a port as I was led to believe. Love this game so much. :D

Also Bizarre Jelly needs to be a real anime. I'd watch it.
 

Regulus Tera

Romanes Eunt Domus
I also feel like the animation of transformations and attacks really lacks impact here. You'd have to go back to Pretty Cure 5 to see something as bland as these.
Toei is busy training their main animators in CGI for the next year's iteration of the franchise. In 3D.
 

DiGiKerot

Member
I don't think I can do the two character thing after Smile. The whole cast needs to be together right from the start. lol

Heartcatch gets away with it a little more by virtue of the fact that they have a lot of guest characters of various degrees of recurringness. To be honest, whilst I've been liking the monster design in it, I think it's something that DokiDoki can learn a lot from - the setup isn't that far from what goes on in Heartcatch, but if nothing else, it'd be neat to actually have the monsters somewhat tie into what's going on in the rest of the episode in DokiDoki more often rather than be mostly random outside of Letter Goat.

I kind of feel that Smile did the whole self-aware humour thing considerably better as well, even whilst being considerably more blatant about it. It's part of my larger problem with DokiDoki in that it hasn't really displayed much personality, at least not of it's own, up until this point, and it's only really with this most recent episode that it's feeling like it's finding it's feet. I'm still not really sure what's supposed to be setting this Precure apart from others, though - I suppose it's showing a much more rigid continuity compared to most of the others, so I wonder if it's going to keep that up across the course of the run.

Also, whilst DokiDoki's humour and direction seem to be gradually improving, it's hard not to notice that, regardless of story content, pretty much any episode of Smile felt more ambitious production-wise - the animation was considerably better, and everything was framed in a far more dynamic fashion. Can't help but wonder if DokiDoki is suffering due to Toei suddenly realising that they're supposed to be remaking Sailor Moon.
 

Regulus Tera

Romanes Eunt Domus
Also, whilst DokiDoki's humour and direction seem to be gradually improving, it's hard not to notice that, regardless of story content, pretty much any episode of Smile feels more ambitious production-wise - the animation was considerably better, and everything was framed in a far more dynamic fashion. Can't help but wonder if DokiDoki is suffering due to Toei suddenly realising that they're supposed to be remaking Sailor Moon.
I totally forgot that was gonna happen. Shit, that's gonna collide with my marathon of the original show. I'm drowning in magical girls.
 

cajunator

Banned
I'm playing through Heroes' Paradise right now (which will be my second time through the game), and it's really nowhere near as bad a port as I was led to believe. Love this game so much. :D

Also Bizarre Jelly needs to be a real anime. I'd watch it.

Most of us would watch it!

I totally forgot that was gonna happen. Shit, that's gonna collide with my marathon of the original show. I'm drowning in magical girls.

This is a good thing isn't it? I want to drown in Mahou shoujo. That would be a good way to go.
 

Articalys

Member
Looks like the To Aru Majutsu no Index movie grossed just over 100 million yen across 30 screens for its opening weekend. Obviously that's no Film Z or Eva, but it's bigger numbers than, say, Star Driver or Blood-C.
 

Risette

A Good Citizen
Back when I played this game I had to clue what moe even meant, I never got the joke when the trailer came out on gaf(first time hearing of it) or when playing the game.

Only found out what moe even was in 2011(maybe late 2010), dissipate having watched anime for 2 decades.

I knew it had something to do with pedophilia and anime.
So when you found out the meaning of moe, you dissipated two decades of anime watching? Weird. Did it come out as a liquid or solid?
 

Westlo

Member
Looks like the To Aru Majutsu no Index movie grossed just over 100 million yen across 30 screens for its opening weekend. Obviously that's no Film Z or Eva, but it's bigger numbers than, say, Star Driver or Blood-C.

Expected though yeah? TV series has sold 10k + 20k and the light novel franchise is a Top 5 for popularity.
 
One good episode is not evidence of a trend.

Well for me precure show sometimes have a slow start .. You can't have a start as great as heartcatch everytime.

This why , seeing doki doki i decided to wait for ep 5 before passsing judgment .. If Ep5 is great , then it'll be perfect , if not then ...well i'll watch it anyway while doing something else.

I do remember watching plenty of Yes precure episodes while doing house chores .
 

Articalys

Member
Nekomimi Rhythm.

Tracked it down to this CD. It was the B-side track to the Maria Holic ED single.

edit: hell, one of the old Amazon Japan reviews for the CD basically boils down to "fuck the title track, the Sawashiro song is what makes the CD worth owning".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom