• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Final Round XV: Cross Assault Survivors Reunion | Fighting game tournament | Mar. 2-4

CheapyD

Member
Anybody know how CAG got involved as a sponsor? CheapyD doesn't seem to know anything about fighting games and he doesn't watch streams AFAIK. On the CAG podcast, any discussion of a fighting game's merits begins and ends with story mode.

I'm friends with Scott Popular and like to support the gaming community when I can.

I haven't played a fighting game "seriously" since Mortal Kombat II. In college (on the SNES version), I would routinely Friendship and Babality my friends without looking at the screen. Also, bong hits.
 

alstein

Member
I'm friends with Scott Popular and like to support the gaming community when I can.

I haven't played a fighting game "seriously" since Mortal Kombat II. In college (on the SNES version), I would routinely Friendship and Babality my friends without looking at the screen. Also, bong hits.

Thanks for sponsoring. I had a blast there.

I think this weekend was the most positive I've been about gaming in general, and the most happy I've been about games themselves, in years.

Makes me want to go next year, maybe I'll learn how to not be a fraud.
 

Neki

Member
I just think it's funny that Kusoru basically won on fundamentals and good space control, rather than pure technical skill. It's refreshing to see, especially because it wasn't some stupid gimmick shit like Phoenix. He won just because he was a more solid and more rounded player.
 

Grecco

Member
people eager to money match him is probably trying to find out how to break that log trap.

Nah they are just salty about a japanese player bodying them in americas game. IT happened when Tokkido won CEO. America is very prideful in Marvel. Funny how so many players hate the game.

Also speaking from experience Pr Rog is kind of a douchebag. Not a suprise that he was disrispecting Mihe or talking shit about Krone lol. Great player though.
 

Zissou

Member
You don't think lack of match-up experience and lack of practicing combos on tiny characters had more to do with Kusoru's success? Players obviously have no excuse for not having bnbs that work on raccoon and joe, but still.
 
They have MK today and pools havent event started yet for the game LOL.

We've never not finished a tournament. Mk finished, but they wanted to run damn near every match at the end on stream, so it dragged it out somewhat, but the MK guys knew what they were doing and handled it.
 

Sixfortyfive

He who pursues two rabbits gets two rabbits.
Nah they are just salty about a japanese player bodying them in americas game.
...Or they just want match-up experience with the new champ using stuff they've never seen or practiced against before. How often do you get the opportunity to play against top Japanese Marvel talent?
 
Also, to anybody from GAF that actually came out, thank you. We appreciate it. It was a really, really tough weekend. Larry's mom passed, Josh's grandpa passed, and we just had a lot of shit going on. The core crew that runs Final Round is like family, so when something happens, it hits us all.

Thanks again for your support.
 
You don't think lack of match-up experience and lack of practicing combos on tiny characters had more to do with Kusoru's success? Players obviously have no excuse for not having bnbs that work on raccoon and joe, but still.



that's exactly what it was. and i can't fault our players that much. Frank is the most popular character on his team in terms of U.S. use and even then, he's considered a specialist character. Only Dieminion uses Joe and no Raccoons have blown up tourneys so far.

I have a feeling, if the game survives a long time, UMVC3 is gonna have a lot of blowups like this.
 

alstein

Member
Anyone have an idea what the payouts typically look like for these major Road to Evo tournaments?

Entry fees were $10, and I think the splits are traditionally 70/20/10
Bigger games have a pot bonus from sponsors.

I knew about the family tragedies, honestly, I think things could have been a bit more organized, but given the situation I understood. Definitely will come next year if I'm still in this. I've wanted to hit majors before, but this was the first time I had a real chance for various reasons. It's been over 10 years since I hit one before this weekend.

I was really thinking of quitting fighting games before coming, now I don't really want to.
 

Oldschoolgamer

The physical form of blasphemy
You don't think lack of match-up experience and lack of practicing combos on tiny characters had more to do with Kusoru's success? Players obviously have no excuse for not having bnbs that work on raccoon and joe, but still.



That may play a part, but the ones from FGTV house didn't really have that excuse. I'm pretty sure i've seen some Norcal folks running RR. Flash Metroid was just at the house last week playing VJ, replicating Die's zone heavy team (Rog was practicing for a MM against Dieminion). It's one thing if you're not around all of the talent, but it's another if you're not branching out when it's right there...
 
I bet you could spam voomerangs + log traps on PSN/XBL just for fun and pick up some salty wins. (not saying his tech was cheap...I wouldn't be able to do all of his keep out tactics at all!)
 
Entry fees were $10, and I think the splits are traditionally 70/20/10
Bigger games have a pot bonus from sponsors.

I knew about the family tragedies, honestly, I think things could have been a bit more organized, but given the situation I understood. Definitely will come next year if I'm still in this. I've wanted to hit majors before, but this was the first time I had a real chance for various reasons. It's been over 10 years since I hit one before this weekend.

I was really thinking of quitting fighting games before coming, now I don't really want to.

What would you have liked to see us do different? This kind of feedback is important to us.
 

Infinite

Member
You don't think lack of match-up experience and lack of practicing combos on tiny characters had more to do with Kusoru's success? Players obviously have no excuse for not having bnbs that work on raccoon and joe, but still.

I wouldn't underestimate that guy's fighting game fundamentals. I pretty sure he would've made top 8 at the very least running something along the lines as a spencer/wesker/magneto.

That may play a part, but the ones from FGTV house didn't really have that excuse. I'm pretty sure i've seen some Norcal folks running RR. Flash Metroid was just at the house last week playing VJ, replicating Die's zone heavy team (Rog was practicing for a MM against Dieminion). It's one thing if you're not around all of the talent, but it's another if you're not branching out when it's right there...

I thought Flash dropped the character. Let's not downplay the Viewtiful Joe Rocket Racoon tandem that Ageo Joe executed perfectly.
 

Guanoape

Neo Member
Once again an awesome tournament. I was kinda hoping that Yipes would win UMvC3, as he definitely improved his game, but I can't possibly be upset about a VJ/Rocket Raccoon team winning. AE was a little less hype, but Wolfkrone's godlike performance more than made up for that. On to Final Round XVI!
 
Funny thing is Skisonic said a month ago that log trap assist was "for scrubs".



key word in this sentence being "Skisonic." Commentators are not top players for a reason! Rocket Raccoon has had obviously strong stuff from day 1, we just haven't seen it leveraged as much until this Japanese guy blew it up. But some Raccoons and Arthurs have been popping up in the U.S. recently. I think Evo will have some crazy character variety. I like seeing UMVC3 grow. It's too insane to be figured out within less than half a year of its release and the stream popularity for it was the highest I've seen it this weekend.



on a side note, it's pretty weird so much Ski and James Chen hate lately though. People must be getting bored of them or something, but they're the guys who have held it down for the past few years and really got me interested in watching FGC streams.
 

GatorBait

Member
Entry fees were $10, and I think the splits are traditionally 70/20/10
Bigger games have a pot bonus from sponsors.

Any idea on what the entrant numbers looked like for SF and UMvC3? Or what the pot bonuses typically look like?

I am considering doing something special for the upcoming major where I live and want to get some ballpark numbers.
 
What would you have liked to see us do different? This kind of feedback is important to us.


I was watching the stream during Marvel I think and Druseph got on the mic and commented how things are running slowly and said lack of set ups was one of the reasons. I guess just not enough space and set ups. Granted I'm not there and I don't know how big the area is but it seems like Final Round is reaching EVO-like numbers. EVO had a gigantic ballroom for the 3000+ players and spectators so although there were tons of people there, it was pretty roomy as well. I'm guessing the Final Round ballroom is much much smaller and had close to 1500 players and spectators. I don't know if it's feasible but maybe trying to get a bigger ball room and more set ups would be a good start.

Again I wasn't there so I'm only going by the stream. Unfortunately I couldn't make it this year due to work, but I think I will definitely come out next year. Great job to you guys and we all look forward to the next one.
 
key word in this sentence being "Skisonic." Commentators are not top players for a reason! Rocket Raccoon has had obviously strong stuff from day 1, we just haven't seen it leveraged as much until this Japanese guy blew it up. But some Raccoons and Arthurs have been popping up in the U.S. recently. I think Evo will have some crazy character variety. I like seeing UMVC3 grow. It's too insane to be figured out within less than half a year of its release and the stream popularity for it was the highest I've seen it this weekend.



on a side note, it's pretty weird so much Ski and James Chen hate lately though. People must be getting bored of them or something, but they're the guys who have held it down for the past few years and really got me interested in watching FGC streams.

You kind of answered it in your own post. They are not top players. Not that anyone needs to be in order to commentate, but having a personal level of experience with a game helps to provide a deeper insight into what's happening in a match. In turn, this provides much more thorough substance for commentary. When they don't have that kind of game insight, they fall back on play-by-play commentating (stating the obvious), maintaining hype, and charisma all of which will be hit-or-miss depending on their abilities.
 

Sixfortyfive

He who pursues two rabbits gets two rabbits.
What would you have liked to see us do different? This kind of feedback is important to us.
Some of the setups were unpatched. I know there was at least one SF4 pool that was running AE instead of AE 2012 and I heard similar things about SC5. Having the people in charge of the pools check the settings beforehand (turning MvC3 auto super jump off, disabling intrusive system notifications, etc) should be mandatory. And DLC is still a pain in the ass in general; a friend of mine that mains Shuma could not find a single casual station with DLC characters to practice on until we started hitting up individual hotel rooms, although I figure that the systems are borrowed from volunteer players and it's not that straightforward to fix this (and is why I'm going to vehemently argue with people who prefer DLC updates to full retail updates from now until the end of time). The NOS stations were running things on Xbox with no patches and sometimes not even the most recent retail release of the game (e.g. vanilla Marvel), although I dunno if you were in charge of that.

I think pools would run somewhat faster if the people running the brackets ran through each loser's bracket round as soon as possible so that people are eliminated from pools as fast as possible and can thus leave without causing any no-show issues later. My pool ran through pretty much all of winner's bracket before starting loser's, and since I lost early in winner's, I had to stick around quite a while waiting for my next match, which was further compounded by the fact that at least one of them predictably vanished for a while and held us up even longer (although this did have the cool side benefit of being able to run several of my matches in a row on stream once he finally showed up).

Most of the issues I ran into were probably just cases of you not having enough resources to adequately handle the turnout. In general, there wasn't enough room or setups for the number of people present, and it seemed like you were under-staffed. Several pools in multiple games were running with just one station for a while. A lot of the floor space was dedicated to seating for the big screen, which I figure would have been better used for additional setups instead. A friend of mine wasn't able to play his first Marvel match until 11:45 PM due to delays. Dunno if anything could have been done about some of this, but that's what came to mind.

EDIT: Not having pool assignments listed until very late was a pretty big inconvenience, and these should have been posted up on the wall at the venue somewhere. Supposedly, SC5(?) had tons of DQs due to people not even knowing when and where they were supposed to be.

EDIT 2: The event badges should have the player's registered alias printed on them somewhere for proof of ID, and the people running brackets should make sure to check them. I don't know of any examples of this happening, but it's not that unfeasible to present yourself as someone else to the people running the brackets. And I was never asked to present my Paypal receipt at the door.
 
I was watching the stream during Marvel I think and Druseph got on the mic and commented how things are running slowly and said lack of set ups was one of the reasons. I guess just not enough space and set ups. Granted I'm not there and I don't know how big the area is but it seems like Final Round is reaching EVO-like numbers. EVO had a gigantic ballroom for the 3000+ players and spectators so although there were tons of people there, it was pretty roomy as well. I'm guessing the Final Round ballroom is much much smaller and had close to 1500 players and spectators. I don't know if it's feasible but maybe trying to get a bigger ball room and more set ups would be a good start.

Again I wasn't there so I'm only going by the stream. Unfortunately I couldn't make it this year due to work, but I think I will definitely come out next year. Great job to you guys and we all look forward to the next one.

Couple things; things ran slowly for a number of reasons, but setups were the big reason. It wasn't a space issue though. Things did get crowded, but it wasn't a space issue. It was a power issue. The hotel we were in simply did not have enough power jacks for us to run what we needed to. We even had an extra generator to provide more power and it still wasn't enough.

Another issue that came up from that was having people go 0-2 and then want to take their systems with them. This used to happen a LOT in the past, and wasn't as bad this year, but I had two of my pools go from 3 tvs to one because somebody went 0-2 and wanted to take their systems and leave. Unfortunately we can't control this, as we are a tournament that depends on the community to help out. We could easily solve this problem if somebody wants to give us about 40 ps3s.

Another thing that held up the pools was the stream. I personally ran 3 different pools, and all my pools finished on time, pretty much ahead of everybody else by a long shot. However, I know that wasn't the case with everybody else and I understand why. I've been doing this since Final Round 3, so I know ways around some of the pitfalls we can run into, and streaming is a new beast for a lot of people running brackets. Wanting people up on the stream can hold up the entire pool especially if the people running the bracket don't know how to work around the hold up. In some cases it simply can't be avoided, and your entire bracket stops because you're waiting on someone to play their match. I ran into that with Mike Ross in one of the AE pools I was running. I wanted him on the stream and simply couldn't make it happen because of the time it would take for him to head up to the stream, wait in line, then play his match.

One thing I'd like to stress, and this has always pissed me off about running tournaments, is that we are open to feedback but we never hear any until months after the tournament is over, and it's people bitching about something we could have fixed had we known WHEN IT HAPPENED.

We don't blow months of our lives planning things like Final Round, just so people can show up and not have a good time. Any hold up, any hiccup, or any technical difficulty is something we take very, very seriously. But we have to know about what's happened, what people liked, what they didn't, etc. I don't want an issue like last year with certain players. That's part of the reason I'm on here right now asking questions, and taking feedback. I want Final Round to be better EVERY year.
 

Bizazedo

Member
Unfortunately we can't control this, as we are a tournament that depends on the community to help out. We could easily solve this problem if somebody wants to give us about 40 ps3s.

You gotta admit, it's not like the tournament organizers re-invest back into their tournaments, though. You'd think with the sponsor money and huge venue revenue and the deals for the hotel rooms (I know, in Philly at least, if you have a big enough group you get the meeting rooms for free) that the tournaments would start stockpiling TV's and systems.

The TV's, especially, if you're using CRT's..you can get one for $20-30 at Goodwill.

Where does all the money go?
 

Sixfortyfive

He who pursues two rabbits gets two rabbits.
Couple things; things ran slowly for a number of reasons, but setups were the big reason. It wasn't a space issue though. Things did get crowded, but it wasn't a space issue. It was a power issue. The hotel we were in simply did not have enough power jacks for us to run what we needed to. We even had an extra generator to provide more power and it still wasn't enough.
I suppose this explains that incident of the entire table next to my pool spontaneously losing power during their matches. >_>
 
You kind of answered it in your own post. They are not top players. Not that anyone needs to be in order to commentate, but having a personal level of experience with a game helps to provide a deeper insight into what's happening in a match. In turn, this provides much more thorough substance for commentary. When they don't have that kind of game insight, they fall back on play-by-play commentating (stating the obvious), maintaining hype, and charisma all of which will be hit-or-miss depending on their abilities.


I'd hardly say they don't know enough to commentate. More importantly, seems like there aren't people who can do a better job and who want to devote all their time to stream commentary.
 

IpKaiFung

Member
You gotta admit, it's not like the tournament organizers re-invest back into their tournaments, though. You'd think with the sponsor money and huge venue revenue and the deals for the hotel rooms (I know, in Philly at least, if you have a big enough group you get the meeting rooms for free) that the tournaments would start stockpiling TV's and systems.

The TV's, especially, if you're using CRT's..you can get one for $20-30 at Goodwill.

Where does all the money go?

I don't know ANY tournament that breaks even on revenue. Most operate on a loss, fuck even MLG barely break even.
 

alstein

Member
I'd hardly say they don't know enough to commentate. More importantly, seems like there aren't people who can do a better job and who want to devote all their time to stream commentary.

This is why someone like UltraDavid, who has the knowledge but can't play at a high level anymore (he has an issue with his hands) , is so valuable.
 

alstein

Member
Any idea on what the entrant numbers looked like for SF and UMvC3? Or what the pot bonuses typically look like?

I am considering doing something special for the upcoming major where I live and want to get some ballpark numbers.

I know for FR it was posted in this thread somewhere. SF/Marvel got the most, then KOF/SC, then it dropped off heavily. Melty did better then MK I think.

BB had only 50.

That said, regional preferences play a big role in numbers. KOF and Melty have stronger then average communities in the Southeast, MK a weaker community.
 

Bizazedo

Member
How many tourneys with big turnouts have you organized?

Two locals with 40+ turnout. Add in to that I started calling hotels and asking for rates on rooms (I've done non-tournament events in the past, so I know how much they run) and that I didn't even have sponsors or any extras....

Non-tournament wise, prior to current job with a bank, I had to schedule and rent out large ballrooms / meeting halls for casting calls and such. I also know a current event planner in Philly.

I know how much those places can run.

It's just a matter of ramping up properly. The reward to effort ratio can go up the bigger you get. The easiest example is room rates / groups. If you jam a hotel with hundreds of rooms, you get concessions on meeting rooms / ballrooms.

I'm not trying to flame them or call them out or anything, because the truth is they might have only broken even or lost money. It's very possible that the hotel could've screwed them / sponsor fell through / something nutty happened and they had to get insurance or got screwed on the rate....

Crazy shit happens.

The tournaments should still start stockpiling some gear, though, with the type of money that's starting to come in.

What was the venue fee for Final Round, $35 online, $40 at the door? I dunno the ratio of door to online, but lets figure ONLY 426 people paid venue (which is BS, it's higher, but lets say).

Lets say they only paid $35. Also BS, it'll run higher.

That's a HAIR under $15,000.

They're not using any of that money for pots and it doesn't include sponsors. It also doesn't include the concessions from the hotel for the rooms / discounts etc.

They made more then that on venue fees, of course, but just throwing it out there. Unsure if they charged for spectators like Winter Brawl did, but that's free money.

The only real curiosity I have is how much sponsors kick in and how much of a deal the hotel gave.

I'm also curious if they sold t-shirts and stuff, to. $10-20 a pop I bet for a shirt? I bet the margin is pretty good, there.
 

LakeEarth

Member
on a side note, it's pretty weird so much Ski and James Chen hate lately though. People must be getting bored of them or something, but they're the guys who have held it down for the past few years and really got me interested in watching FGC streams.
I hate it when people diss James Chen. He might not be the top commentator, but he has a skill that not a lot of commentators have. Down time banter. Ultra-Chen combo works so great because they can keep your attention when nothing has been happening on the screen for 10-15 minutes.

Whenever you just get 2 random guys paired up, when there's nothing going on they just make a comment, the other says something, and the conversation is dead until one of them can think of something else to say. Repeat.
 
You kind of answered it in your own post. They are not top players.

They commented well enough considering how little was known about the Joe/RR/Frank matchup vs any other team. The discussions on that makeup and how to counter it are still in their infancy so I doubt we could have done much better with 'veteran' UMVC3 players on the mic with the color. Ski knows Marvel and has been commenting on it for years now. And this was not a good weekend to start experimenting with fresh, unpredictable blood behind the caster table.
 
You gotta admit, it's not like the tournament organizers re-invest back into their tournaments, though. You'd think with the sponsor money and huge venue revenue and the deals for the hotel rooms (I know, in Philly at least, if you have a big enough group you get the meeting rooms for free) that the tournaments would start stockpiling TV's and systems.

The TV's, especially, if you're using CRT's..you can get one for $20-30 at Goodwill.

Where does all the money go?

Let me clarify who I am. My name is Leigh, I've been running these tournaments with Larry for over 10 years. I'm well aware of what's going on internally in our organization and it's a kind of funny that you think we aren't reinvesting back into our tournaments since you don't know what we do or how we do it. But that's alright. I'll break down some of the issues that we've run into.

A big issue, probably the biggest, has to do with the fact that a lot of places in Atlanta aren't interested in having a bunch of rowdy 15-25 year olds running around in their hotels fucking shit up. That stuff is expected in Vegas, but not in Atlanta. We also need to find a venue that won't price people out of coming to our tournament due to traveling costs. I know a lot of people are upset that Ceaser's is really expensive this year for Evo. That room price has already stopped some of my friends from being able to come to Vegas. We don't want to have that happen to our tournament, because realistically, who wants to pay 200 a night to come to Atlanta? It's a great city, but 600 for a weekend to just hang out in a hotel? That can work in Vegas because it's Vegas and there are 300 things to do that are in walking distance. Atlanta just isn't like that.

So it comes down to trying to find a good price point that's affordable, but also isn't in a shitty hotel that nobody wants to be in. AND that hotel has to be okay with the masses that come out for these tournaments. Some who don't seem like they have ANY home training.

As for the idea that we don't reinvest into our own tournament, that's ridiculous. This started with a core group of us, and was pretty much underground with no sponsorship until about 2 years ago. Everything was done out of pocket with no help but from those in the community. Now we're transitioning to having sponsors, a huge influx of new people, and trying to accomidate all of that without going broke. It's very difficult. There are a lot more costs to running a tournament besides the hotel and the ballroom.

And also, since you brought up hotels and meeting rooms, can you find me a NICE play in Philly where they can give you a ballroom that's big enough to house 1500 people, if you book some rooms, that won't break the bank? I think you're massively underestimating how different the group of people we deal with is from a group of business people.

Also, tournament players are notorious for showing up at the last minute. It's very hard to plan what you need when people don't pre-register. We were taking at the door signups for games until 4 or 5 on friday. We intended to close that at noon, but there was a GRIP of people outside. We weren't going to turn them away. Had we known all those people were coming, we would have been able to plan better. But we're not going to get supplies, rent space, and everything associated with that for 500 people we think MIGHT show up.

We are stockpiling gear, btw. We have been for a while. Our attendence this year was basically double that of last year. Which is why we have to depend on the community to help. If you have a contact with Asus or Sony that I could talk to, I'd be all ears. I'd love to have enough systems on hand that we never have to worry about anything, believe me, I would.

Our current sponsors have been incredible and really REALLY shown up for the community, but this isn't something like Starcraft. I think a lot of people falsely think that there are hundreds of companies out there willing to throw hundreds of thousands of dollars at tournaments that have 1500-3000 people, and there aren't. People like Cheapy D, who help out, do it because they want to, not because they'll get something back. Companies like Toyota, who sponsored Evo one year, want a return that they simply aren't going to see with a market like the fighting game community.

You're sitting here basically making up numbers when you don't seem to understand the logistics of something this big. No offense. I understand how things work for a 40 man tournament. I've run those. I've also helped run a tournament that had over 1000 people. There's a lot more involved than just going 'Okay, how much is this, how much is this, PROFIT!" It doesn't work that way. You yourself even said "Hey, they might have broken even or lost money" and then turn around and come up with a scenario where we're rolling in dough. That's so far from the truth it's not even funny. No one at final Round is making loads of money and just keeping it. Over the course of running this tournament for 15 years, trust me, Larry is still at a HUGE loss.
 

Bizazedo

Member
Let me clarify who I am. My name is Leigh, I've been running these tournaments with Larry for over 10 years. I'm well aware of what's going on internally in our organization and it's a kind of funny that you think we aren't reinvesting back into our tournaments since you don't know what we do or how we do it. But that's alright. I'll break down some of the issues that we've run into.

Oh, I wasn't attacking you guys. Just speaking in generalities. If you are re-investing, that's awesome. It doesn't seem like many do, though, which is a shame when the fact is they have the chance to.

A big issue, probably the biggest, has to do with the fact that a lot of places in Atlanta aren't interested in having a bunch of rowdy 15-25 year olds running around in their hotels fucking shit up. That stuff is expected in Vegas, but not in Atlanta. We also need to find a venue that won't price people out of coming to our tournament due to traveling costs. I know a lot of people are upset that Ceaser's is really expensive this year for Evo. That room price has already stopped some of my friends from being able to come to Vegas. We don't want to have that happen to our tournament, because realistically, who wants to pay 200 a night to come to Atlanta? It's a great city, but 600 for a weekend to just hang out in a hotel? That can work in Vegas because it's Vegas and there are 300 things to do that are in walking distance. Atlanta just isn't like that.
Yeah, I was kind of surprised by that too when checking out Vegas. On the bright side, can get $89 a night rooms just down the street at Treasure Island and others, so let them know that.

As for the idea that we don't reinvest into our own tournament, that's ridiculous. This started with a core group of us, and was pretty much underground with no sponsorship until about 2 years ago. Everything was done out of pocket with no help but from those in the community. Now we're transitioning to having sponsors, a huge influx of new people, and trying to accomidate all of that without going broke. It's very difficult. There are a lot more costs to running a tournament besides the hotel and the ballroom.
No, it's not easy. And like I said above, although I can see WHY you interpreted it that way, I'm not explicitly targetting you guys. Another tourney organizer I know specifically said to me never to spend any of my own money, which I rolled my eyes hard at and have since been trying to get rid of the taste of it in my mouth :(.
And also, since you brought up hotels and meeting rooms, can you find me a NICE play in Philly where they can give you a ballroom that's big enough to house 1500 people, if you book some rooms, that won't break the bank? I think you're massively underestimating how different the group of people we deal with is from a group of business people.

Depends, am I getting $35-40 per person? If so, perhaps I could.

Also, tournament players are notorious for showing up at the last minute. It's very hard to plan what you need when people don't pre-register. We were taking at the door signups for games until 4 or 5 on friday. We intended to close that at noon, but there was a GRIP of people outside. We weren't going to turn them away. Had we known all those people were coming, we would have been able to plan better. But we're not going to get supplies, rent space, and everything associated with that for 500 people we think MIGHT show up.

I feel for you there. That sucks balls :(.
We are stockpiling gear, btw. We have been for a while. Our attendence this year was basically double that of last year. Which is why we have to depend on the community to help. If you have a contact with Asus or Sony that I could talk to, I'd be all ears. I'd love to have enough systems on hand that we never have to worry about anything, believe me, I would.

I hear you. I know that's why I'm starting my own little stockpile myself, but that's because I have no life :(.

You're sitting here basically making up numbers when you don't seem to understand the logistics of something this big. No offense. I understand how things work for a 40 man tournament. I've run those. I've also helped run a tournament that had over 1000 people. There's a lot more involved than just going 'Okay, how much is this, how much is this, PROFIT!" It doesn't work that way. You yourself even said "Hey, they might have broken even or lost money" and then turn around and come up with a scenario where we're rolling in dough.

I know there is. Like I said before, if you're re-investing, that's great.

Question, did you cap entrants, or was it take everyone?
 
They commented well enough considering how little was known about the Joe/RR/Frank matchup vs any other team. The discussions on that makeup and how to counter it are still in their infancy so I doubt we could have done much better with 'veteran' UMVC3 players on the mic with the color. Ski knows Marvel and has been commenting on it for years now.

I was making an overall statement, not just on one match. Anyone would've been miffed by Kusoru's team and I understand that.

But the stream casters can have whoever they want commentating for them. In the end, it's about who's there and available so I'll just stop beating the horse.

And this was not a good weekend to start experimenting with fresh, unpredictable blood behind the caster table.

Juicebox Abel.
 

dankir

Member
Question about the commentators. Do SkiSonic, James Chen and Ultra David pay their own way to commentate at these events?
 

GatorBait

Member
http://finalround.org/ all the numbers for the tournaments are on that site.

429 for SF4 and 405 for UMVC3

I know for FR it was posted in this thread somewhere. SF/Marvel got the most, then KOF/SC, then it dropped off heavily. Melty did better then MK I think.

BB had only 50.

That said, regional preferences play a big role in numbers. KOF and Melty have stronger then average communities in the Southeast, MK a weaker community.

Thanks for the information, guys. I'm going to contact the organizer and see if he has any interest and/or needs any assistance.

I hate it when people diss James Chen. He might not be the top commentator, but he has a skill that not a lot of commentators have. Down time banter. Ultra-Chen combo works so great because they can keep your attention when nothing has been happening on the screen for 10-15 minutes.

Whenever you just get 2 random guys paired up, when there's nothing going on they just make a comment, the other says something, and the conversation is dead until one of them can think of something else to say. Repeat.

Anyone who watches sports knows how big of a deal chemistry is between commentators. It is the perfect example of the whole being greater than the sum of its parts. The best duos have healthy doses of color commentary, technical knowledge, banter, and the ability to amplify the tensions of the game. Ideally, they should be able to keep you entertained, teach you something, and add to the emotional flow of the game (while not crossing that fine line where they distract from the centerpiece of the entertainment, which is the game).

It's great to see certain individuals working on improving their skills together in this area. It is something we should be nurturing, especially considering FG stream commentary is still in its relative infancy.
 
...Or they just want match-up experience with the new champ using stuff they've never seen or practiced against before. How often do you get the opportunity to play against top Japanese Marvel talent?

Maybe kusoru was uncomfortable with the money match aspect of it and people trying tp push that on him.

Did he turn down casual matches? I'm sure if people just wanted games with a top player and to learn the log trap match up, a casual set would be more than ok.

It seems like some people (not all) wanted revenge with a money match to prove something, haha. Everything doesn't have to be a money match.

Who knows though. Only kusoru and the people asking for those particular money matches know (who knows the manner in which they asked him for them).
 

USD

Member

Sixfortyfive

He who pursues two rabbits gets two rabbits.
Maybe kusoru was uncomfortable with the money match aspect of it and people trying tp push that on him.
If he doesn't want matches, then he's free to enjoy the rest of the weekend however he likes.

It's just beyond stupid to assume that many of the people who want games in with him are xenophobic assholes or whatever.
 
Top Bottom