Swoop said:
Pah, choose a real rugby team if you want to really compare the two sports. You'll never get a decent hit from those L.A boys, get an All Black in there, that'll show you a real hit!
Blackface said:
Did you just link something where
A) They used La's "rugby team" as an example of strong and good Rugby players. LOOOOOOOOL
B) They made the Rugby player hit a PERSON
C) They allowed the football player to hit a dummies, with two hands, pushing it to double the force due to small impact points?
Do Football players hit harder, yes. Simply because of the nature of the game. Timing, knowing opposing teams plays, predictability and gear.
Both different sports. You put a football player into a rugby game and he won't hit as hard. You put a Rugby player into a football game, and he could hit just as hard(both with training).
Pssssst.... just a clue for you guys, because you obviously need one. When the Sports Science guys said Quentin Jammer was one of the hardest hitters in football, everybody who knows about football laughed. You guys just didn't get the joke.
He isn't one of the hardest hitters at all. He's a cornerback. The hardest hitters in football are
never cornerbacks, they are ends, linebackers and safeties.
So go ahead and put the best the All-Blacks have to offer in there, and we'll put someone who closes about as fast as Jammer, but brings 65-85 lbs. more muscle with him.
...
Opiate said:
Not really a fan of many sports, but I will say this: the best sports are, to me, the sports that do not encourage hugely disproportionate body types of lifestyles.
That is, sports that seem to be played best by people of average height and average build (but can therefore still be played by tall or shorter people reasonably well) appeal to me more than sports that hugely favor people who are extremely tall (like basketball) or extremely fat (like sumo wrestling or some parts of american football) or extremely short (like gymnastics). Instead, the predominant necessary physical quality is simply being in great shape.
Examples of sports that vaguely fit this description are Rugby, European Rules Football, and Tennis.
This is a completely
shitty attitude I think.
Sport can teach us lessons about humanity, right? Isn't that always the lesson behind the Olympics?
Well, sports like our football teach a valuable lesson. Everybody can bring their own unique attributes to the team to make it better. The big, lumbering guys have a place on the team. The tiny, speedy guys have a place on the team. The guys who are really smart have a place. The guys who get by on brawn have a place. The team will be stronger for the diversity of people. You don't have to fit into a mold. You can bring your unique talent to the game.
...
Also, you act like "extremely fat" is the norm in football. You even compare it to sumo. That is the most daft thing I've ever heard. It really shows you have no idea what you are talking about.
On any football field at any one time, there are 22 players on the team. How many are even close to fat? Maybe five or six, maximum. Usually, there's only like four or five--usually around two per team, right in the middle of the line. Those are the interior linemen. (Interesting factoid--offensive linemen, the huge guys most people who are ignorant of the game would think are just brutes, are actually usually highly intelligent. The smartest guys on the field according to the IQ tests. They have to be smart. The position is actually very cerebral. And often their college degrees reflect this.)
But even most linemen aren't fat.
This is 6'7" 315lbs. offensive lineman Lydon Murtha without the pads on. You wanna call him fat?:
What about the other side of the ball? This is 6'4" 310lbs. Defensive Lineman Ndamukong Suh, generally considered to be the prototype for the modern NFL defensive lineman:
Fat?
Here's a picture of him long jumping:
"Extremely fat?" Those are
all defensive linemen standing in the background. I don't see any sumo wrestlers.
The fact is, in the modern NFL, actual "fat" guys are really rare now. Guys who are over 300lbs. and wear it well are more the norm.
So, now we are more educated about linemen. Who makes up the rest of the 22 players on a football field? Are they, as you claim, "hugely disproportionate body types of lifestyles" or are they closer to your idea of just "being in great shape" through hard work and conditioning? (NOTE: I didn't go picking out guys who are well-known to have spectacular physiques for their positions, so Terrell Owens for example, doesn't represent the wide receivers here. I tried to go for more representative samples)
There's the quarterback, of course. Here's what one looks like:
That's Peyton Manning.
How 'bout the running backs? Here's one:
That's Adrian Peterson.
How about the wide receivers? Here's Miles Austin:
Tight Ends? Here's Vernon Davis:
So, those are all the other major positions on the football field on offense. Let's see the positions that round out the defense...
Linebackers. Here's Shawne Merriman:
Defensive backs? Here's Safety Troy Polamalu:
...
WARCOCK said:
I'm with opiate on this one, i think the most desirable quality in an athletic sport is a game defined by a set of rules that limits physical bias as much as possible. Arguably the best footballer of all time was 5 foot 5... it's not how you were born, it's what you have it in you to become.
A football team where everyone looks the same is a football team that will always lose. I think that's better than you guys' dream sport where everybody looks relatively the same.
And as far as your oh-so-touching story about your 5'5" soccer player, well, first off, Pele was 5'8" and a physical beast,
...and second, if you weren't so quick to arrogantly write off football, you'd know that those stories exist all over this sport as well.
Want an example? Meet Wes Welker:
Wes is 5'8" and 180 lbs. That's
tiny in football.
Wes is quick, but not particularly fast for a wide receiver.
Wes wasn't recruited out of high school to play college ball. He played for a small high school in Oklahoma. He wasn't even offered a scholarship to play football until a player backed out of an offer at the last minute, leaving Texas Tech University with an empty scholarship spot. But Wes made the best of it, and through hard work on and off the field, became a very good wide receiver, and one of the best punt returners in NCAA history, tying the record for punt returns, which still hasn't been broken.
Despite his impressive numbers, when Wes got out of college, nobody in the pros drafted him. Not one team believed he could make it in the NFL. They thought he was too small, too white, and not fast enough.
He eventually signed on to try to return punts for one team, then another, where he got a chance to play offense, and eventually became their best wide receiver.
Then, he moved on to the New England Patriots where he became one of the best wide receivers in the game. In 2007, he would tie the Super Bowl record for the most receptions in the game. In 2009, he would catch the second-most passes in a single season in the history of the NFL.
If that's not a story of "it's not how you were born, it's what you have it in you to become," then I don't know what one is...