• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Winter of Anime 2013 |OT -6| How much lower can we go?!

Status
Not open for further replies.

yami4ct

Member
I'll reiterate the same argument I've made against Lelouch here before. If he had some actually likable characters around him, he would've worked. He was just made more awful because everyone else sucked as well. There needs to be a straight man. A likable balance to the insanity. That's the thing Geass lacks.
 

cajunator

Banned
Definitely an "Oh shit!" moment. I was so mad.

I just couldn't stop laughing.
Im awful :(

Fate/Zero 1

Everyone is directly related to each other. Also, they all want to kill each other. Sounds good.

Anyway, I guess series I'm really interested in watching are:

Gurren Laggan
Spice and Wolf
Cowboy Bebop
Nichojou

It would help if there was a MangaUpdates-like site to keep track of this stuff.

Nice beginning list!
 

Ultimadrago

Member
I'll reiterate the same argument I've made against Lelouch here before. If he had some actually likable characters around him, he would've worked. He was just made more awful because everyone else sucked as well. There needs to be a straight man. A likable balance to the insanity. That's the thing Geass lacks.

You could not sympathize with poor Orange-kun?
 

Regulus Tera

Romanes Eunt Domus
Superflat Monogram

Yet another Hosoda work with imagery that will be familiar to anyone who has watched Summer Wars. This short is essentially just an advertisement for Louis Vuitton, but not many commercials have been created as a music video collaboration between Mamoru Hosoda and superflat artist Takashi Murakami. In any case, it's only five minutes, so there's not really any good reason not to watch it.
Louis Vuitton are monsters.
Too bad the second Monogram was CGI entirely and it sucked. :(
 

fertygo

Member
I'll reiterate the same argument I've made against Lelouch here before. If he had some actually likable characters around him, he would've worked. He was just made more awful because everyone else sucked as well. There needs to be a straight man. A likable balance to the insanity. That's the thing Geass lacks.

How the hell you put Tomino's Gundam on pedestal then?

"Everyone are asshole" were his favorite trope.

I'm consistent so I like both!
 

CorvoSol

Member
Well I wouldn't argue that Renton is a good mecha protagonist, I don't think anyone could say he's as bad or worse than Flit.

I would. Renton is a dorky boy who grows into a man who can kick ass in a giant robot and shout with the best of them. He's as mecha protagonist as they come. Excluding regular hot-blooded always shouting types.

This sounds like something worth watching.

Did I mention it was written by Motomu Toriyama?

Rah Xephon 9

Even when things happen in this show, it's still boring as heck. Rah Xephon is Evangelion if Evangelion were voice acted entirely by Ben Stein.
 

yami4ct

Member
How the hell you put Tomino's Gundam on pedestal then?

"Everyone are asshole" were his favorite trope.

I'm consistent so I like both!

They have development at least. Amuro and even Char develop over the course of their series. They become lesser assholes. Some people are actually likable there. Geass just takes it too far to the extreme.
 

Branduil

Member
Code Geass is a great show. Solid action, solid comedy. The writing played to the strengths of the material, and it was incredibly memorable. Not a surprise that it remains incredibly popular and ironic long after it has ended.

A series can be memorable and popular without being great, though.
 

Milamber

Member
ulDTQUX.jpg




I remember the vitriolic internet reaction to Geass R2. I thoroughly enjoyed all of Code Geass and the conclusive solution of Lelouch. The entire 2 seasons establish him as essentially a siscon and everyone there serves to hinder his views on her happiness.
 

Dead

well not really...yet
Code Geass is a great show. Solid action, solid comedy. The writing played to the strengths of the material, and it was incredibly memorable. Not a surprise that it remains incredibly popular and ironic long after it has ended.
what happened to you duckroll.
 

Dresden

Member
I'll reiterate the same argument I've made against Lelouch here before. If he had some actually likable characters around him, he would've worked. He was just made more awful because everyone else sucked as well. There needs to be a straight man. A likable balance to the insanity. That's the thing Geass lacks.

0ZFNQB2.jpg
 

iavi

Member
Gintama Benizakura Movie

Oh wow, it's even better the second time around. I don't know how to feel about seeing some of you imply that this is the highest point of the show so far. What exactly do you guys mean by that? Should I temper my expectations going forward?

Hell no. The upcoming srsbiz arcs are some of the best the series has offered yet. Benizakura is only the tip of it all.

You'll see what I'm saying when you hit the Four Divas arc.

W: whoa, really beaten. Thank God.
 

fertygo

Member
For real though, the time when Geass aired was the best time on internet.. I guess that also playing big part why people fond of it lol
 

JCG

Member
A series can be memorable and popular without being great, though.

Absolutely true, but Code Geass and Lelouch, for that matter, still aren't nearly as bad as yami4ct says they are.

You want a show without any likable main characters? That's closer to Guilty Crown if anything.

But then again, I realize different people like/hate different characters/series (oh how shocking!).
 

Dead

well not really...yet
Even though Geass Season 1 went off the rails at the end, it was still salvageable with a 2nd season.

Too bad Sunrise just said fuck it and went full on imbecilic. Rolo. lol. LOL.

Lelouch is likeable though. If you want unlikeable, HATEFUL characters, then you have CC and Kallen.
 

yami4ct

Member
Even though Geass Season 1 went off the rails at the end, it was still salvageable with a 2nd season.

Too bad Sunrise just said fuck it and went full on imbecilic. Rolo. lol. LOL.

Lelouch is likeable though. If you want unlikeable, HATEFUL characters, then you have CC and Kallen.

Kallen is terrible but LuLu is way worse. I sort of enjoyed how awful CC was.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom