Went and saw the movie tonight. We gave are daughter the option between this out Star Trek and she chose this. At seven, she really enjoyed it. Think my wife enjoyed it more than she thought she would, but she did comment that she thought the original was funnier. I honestly went not expecting much, I don't really like Feig movies, and it was a little better than I thought it would be.
The movie seemed to rely too much on the original while not actually capturing the feeling of the original. It seemed like they wanted to give a callback to everything about the original movie but felt they had to do something to make it different. The mayor is an example of this that really just annoyed me. Guess he was supposed to be stupid (honestly seemed like everyone who wasn't a Ghostbuster was supposed to be dumb) and really felt that all the scenes with him were pretty bad and slowed down any momentum the movie was getting. Should have just had it brought up in passing that the mayor was going to call them frauds but that they were working for him.
The bad guy also just didn't seem very Ghostbusters like. Gozer and Vigo both setup ways to come back and seemed like they could actually end the world, or at least destroy the city. Rowan really didn't have any weight behind him. He was just a guy that wanted to bring back the dead, no real history there. It might seem cheesy, but at least looking up Sumerian or Carpathian actually gets me somewhere and I can see how Akroyd and co came up with a plot based on those. Rowan has no real history behind him and they really didn't sell it as any kind of threat.
Also not a fan of the weapons. The idea I guess is ok, but they don't get any kind of consistency. I guess the pistol and shotgun use different lasers than the proton packs since the proton packs can't actually 'kill' a ghost but everything else can. Just seemed like they needed to have a way for a big finish and decided to make weapons that allowed for it. I did like seeing the evolution of the proton pack though.
I really didn't find any of it funny. There was a few times that I chuckled, but I think that was mostly at Kevin being dumb. I did actually like Melissa McCarthy in this more than any other movie she has been in. Leslie Jones character is not nearly as bad in the movie as the promos let on. She was actually very good and wish they would have used her more in the movie. Kristen Wiig was pretty good, just don't think I liked her lines or character. I also was bummed that they tried to use the shell of the four original, but they really didn't get any of them right, and besides Patty, didn't really make anyone memorable. Holtzman was like a slapstick Egon, which just didn't work for me. They were also missing someone with Rays love of the paranormal. They tried with Abby, but outside the first encounter, it just didn't seem like she loved the paranormal. Missing someone that was always excited by every encounter and would even be speechless because of it just kept them from selling it to me.
The cameos were all ok. A couple seemed really forced, but was nice to see them.
I'm not sure what I would have wanted this movie to be more, but I am sure I didn't enjoy the way it tried to safely walk the remake but not line. There was just way too much that was from the original to not make comparisons directly to it, and I don't think this version really holds up to the original. There is nothing in this movie nearly as funny or memorable as 'go ahead, tell him about the twinkie.'. No support characters even on Walter Pecks level. No 'history' behind it. I am glad that my seven year old liked it though.