• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

RWBY |OT| Volume 5 starts October 14, 2017

Status
Not open for further replies.

Veelk

Banned
I really wish they'd refine the humor of the series. The Juane joke this episode stands out for me here.
Had Weiss just opened the door, had him sing a few notes, and then slam it in his face, that'd have been hilarious and moved on. Instead, they dragged it on, making it lose the humor value, and especially by having him sing awfully more, and let me tell you, humor in awfulness is a very dangerous gambit, because you are still subjecting your audience to the awfulness. I have a pet peeve about annoying sounds, so it grated on me. Besides, characterwise, Weiss slamming the door in his face and leaving it at that, without any more consideration, would have lived more up to the ice queen nature of her name, because she rejects him without even really giving him time to finish. Or go another way, and have her elaborate on how unworthy he is of her to crush him beyond all hope. That might take some of the humor aspect out of it, but it would give him greater impetus to be sad, because right now it's just the same as every other time she has rejected him and still being more important to her ice queen nature. As it is....I mean, this is a guy who hounded her since the first day of the first semester, and she's given numerous cues that she's not interested. I can't begrudge her not bothering with subtlety.

And while I get that his crush is shallow, it's kind of perplexing that he's still pining for her. Weiss says it's the family name, but....I don't pitch Juane as the kind that cares about that. In fact, none of the characters in the show have given 2 shits about her family name (well, blake did, but not in a positive way). So I don't know if this is a case of telling, not showing, or if Juane really just likes his waifu's white and bitchy.
 
$15 for 6 months, that should cover the run time of a Volume.

Up in 30 minutes for site members.

Also lets you watch the podcasts live, which is pretty cool. Especially the main one, which doesn't go up in video form for a week.

That's a better deal than I was expecting for $15.

It looks like Crunchyroll messed up the broadcast. Still shows no image or title for episode 5 and the video player doesn't even load when you try to watch it. Rooster Teeth it is!
 

Voror

Member
I really wish they'd refine the humor of the series. The Juane joke this episode stands out for me here.
Had Weiss just opened the door, had him sing a few notes, and then slam it in his face, that'd have been hilarious and moved on. Instead, they dragged it on, making it lose the humor value, and especially by having him sing awfully more, and let me tell you, humor in awfulness is a very dangerous gambit, because you are still subjecting your audience to the awfulness. I have a pet peeve about annoying sounds, so it grated on me. Besides, characterwise, Weiss slamming the door in his face and leaving it at that, without any more consideration, would have lived more up to the ice queen nature of her name, because she rejects him without even really giving him time to finish. Or go another way, and have her elaborate on how unworthy he is of her to crush him beyond all hope. That would also give him greater impetus to be sad, because right now it's just the same as every other time she has rejected him.

And while I get that his crush is shallow, it's kind of perplexing that he's still pining for her. Weiss says it's the family name, but....I don't pitch Juane as the kind that cares about that. In fact, none of the characters in the show have given 2 shits about her family name (well, blake did, but not in a positive way). So I don't know if this is a case of telling, not showing, or if Juane really just likes his waifu's white and bitchy.

Agreed.
The humor with the show is one of the things I tend to have the most problem with, which is a bit depressing since I think their other work is quite funny. Had they done what you said then it would have been a nice funny bit. Add to that my continued confusion as well regarding this Jaune going after Weiss thing. I remembered him hitting on her a few times the first season, but figured he'd gotten over it. He doesn't seem the type to care about that much either. I wouldn't mind him perhaps explaining why he's attracted to her.

And goddamn his obliviousness regarding Phyrra irritates me.

I'm still curious what Cinder's actual goal for all this is. Wanton chaos and destruction of Beacon's best and brightest I can get, but what's the ultimate endgame for this. Take over the world? Watch the world burn?
 
That was a pretty sweet fight scene.
Also I liked Cinder when she was some evil mastermind. But why does she run around masquerading as a schoolgirl? It's just a tad ridiculous that she's talking about her evil plans with the seductive villain voice cranked up to 11 in the middle of a dormitory. She has to be the most unconvincing student in existence.
 

naeS

Member
The
sparring matches were cool, sly Mercury doing some scouting. Weiss still the Ice Queen. That scene did drag on a bit but was still pretty funny. I think Blake is going hit a wall if she keeps up what she is doing, it might be bad for RWBY in the end. And lol at Jaune oblivious to Pyrrah, saw it coming. And Cinder, what is she planning? What is this list? AHHHH!!!

This episode left me wanting, hurry up next Thursday...


EDIT:

Also, first mention of
Team CFVY!
 
My thoughts for this episode.

- Pyrrha was amazing. It was a nice surprise to see them open with a sparring scene.

- Team CRDL had a better showing here than in the last season even though they still lost.

- I was crossing my fingers that Mercury would pick out Yang as his opponent. It'll happen someday.

- Mercury is badass.

- Seems that Mercury and presumably Emerald and Cinder are scouting for students that could be a threat to whatever they're planning.

- I hope Jaune eventually moves on from Weiss. I don't want to see him pining for her in all of his appearances.

- I chalk up his obliviousness for Pyrrha to him thinking that she wouldn't have any interest in him due to their difference in prowess. Noted how he mentioned that she probably already has more capable suitors asking her out which would mean that he thinks he has no chance (so why even start kind of thing).

- Jaune's guitar scene was alright. Like I said before I don't want the majority of his appearances to be focused around getting shutdown by Weiss. If they do do that it kind of cheapens the development he's gone through so far (season 1). That development needs to continue.

- So semblances can be discovered through training. I imagine that Jaune's is probably defense oriented given his armaments and his position as the team leader.

- Blake is probably going to burn herself out. Her rematch with Torchwick will not go well in her current state. She has the most stake in the situation with the White Fang and given her history with them it makes sense that she wants to get to the bottom of what they're doing with Torchwick (also considering that it was her who wanted to investigate outside of Beacon in the first place).

- Mercury versus Yang needs to happen.
 

coolasj19

Why are you reading my tag instead of the title of my post?
First off, I wouldn't worry one bit about Juane x Pyrrha. In the S2 trailer they show stuff from the dance and it gets really obvious where that's going.

Pyrrha is the most videogamey fighting character. She did a goddamn airjuggle for goodness sake! She was pisssssssssed when Mercury gave up. I could feel it in her burning hatred/disappointed stare.

It's really obvious Blake is gonna burn out really really bad right about next episode. Why does she haven't the biggest sense of justice in the group? Because it involves the White Fang?

Our RWBY girls don't know the "Dance Rejection Heartbreak". Not like Juane didn't fucking beg for it though. That bit of humor was super cringe. They should have kept that dead after the first slam in the face. Dude needs to see Pyrrha so we can be done with this sub-plot. The show will improve when it's wrapped up. But not until after one more Juane x Pyrrha rooftop hearttalk.

The girl talk real talk this episode was good though. Good to see they do this every once in a while. They're such good teammates/roommates for each other.

Actually, I hope the drama ends by next (The Dance) next (The Fallout From The Dance) episode. I don't want them overspending their drama allowance like they did in S1.

And, Cinders rigging was just noticeably bad. But was she sewing up a new Dust dress?

It seems they've wisened up and decided to pair drama with action. I hope they do it next week too. Because this was by my opinion the weakest episode so far, but far better than any School Episode from S1.

I say that, but I've already watched it 3 times =)

EDIT : Oh yeah. Cinder! You're way too old to be pretending to be a schoolgirl! Seriously!
 

DominoKid

Member
Jaune cracks me up and i can't wait until he starts giving out that work later in the show.

i like that Pyrhha doesn't go OD with her powers and that it's going to be a plot point (minor but very relevant) going forward.
 
The only kinds of enemies that get dispatched by the ranged component of a weapon are usually grunts unless the ranged component is the main component of the weapon or the user employs some risky gambit that ends up surprising their opponent leaving them unable to defend themselves in time.

You can think of it as something like hadoukens in street fighter, used for ranged pressure and controlling spacing, not really your main way of dealing damage given that all of your other moves and specials are melee.

We all know Juane is gonna be a huge badass come Season 4. And hopefully, a bit more perspective.

Maybe even sooner than that, since he'll be discovering his semblance any day now!

Gray (Producer, voice of Torchwick) and JJ (voice of Mercury) are going to be on http://site.afterbuzztv.com/ in about half an hour.

I forgot to tune in to this.

At least they've put up a podcast version.
 

Kyuur

Member
Aw yees, more Pyrrha action. Sparring was excellent, everything involving Jaune pains me (I was kind of rooting for him to get awesome with Pyrrha, but this love triangle..) and Blake needs to chin up. Overall, I liked this episode far better than the last. I think the city is just a boring setting for me compared to the school/forest/ruins.
 

coolasj19

Why are you reading my tag instead of the title of my post?
Wait wait wait wait wait wait wait...
"It'll be fun! Yang and I will make sure of it" - Best Girl
Weiss
"Yeah! We're planning the whole event!" - Yang
"Excuse me?" - Blake
"Team Coffee's ( The team with "Bunny Girl"?
Velvet
) away mission lasted longer than expected." - Weiss
"So, Weiss and I were asked to pick up where they left off. So we can make sure you have the perfect night." - Yang

Oh god... I... I don't know what the consequences of them planning the dance are.
 
Aw yees, more Pyrrha action. Sparring was excellent, everything involving Jaune pains me (I was kind of rooting for him to get awesome with Pyrrha, but this love triangle..) and Blake needs to chin up. Overall, I liked this episode far better than the last. I think the city is just a boring setting for me compared to the school/forest/ruins.

I agree that the sparring part at the beginning was amazing. I'm excited because I think we're going to get a bunch of a fights like that this season because of what's currently going on in the story.

Wait wait wait wait wait wait wait...
"It'll be fun! Yang and I will make sure of it" - Best Girl
Weiss
"Yeah! We're planning the whole event!" - Yang
"Excuse me?" - Blake
"Team Coffee's ( The team with "Bunny Girl"?
Velvet
) away mission lasted longer than expected." - Weiss
"So, Weiss and I were asked to pick up where they left off. So we can make sure you have the perfect night." - Yang

Oh god... I... I don't know what the consequences of them planning the dance are.

Whatever they are it looks like
Cinder
is going to mess them up next week.
 


Here are the others -


Miles Luna (writer, voice of Jaune) and Kerry Shawcross (writer, voice of Neptune)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KL3J__I7qXA

Monty Oum (series creator, lead animator, voice of Ren)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ykADdGwqwpU

Lindsey Jones (voive of Ruby) and Kara Eberle (voice of Weiss)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AEE80lvdkYI




also, here are the voice actresses all cosplaying their characters at RTX:

XcUmOYb.jpg
 
Here are the others -


Miles Luna (writer, voice of Jaune) and Kerry Shawcross (writer, voice of Neptune)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KL3J__I7qXA

Monty Oum (series creator, lead animator, voice of Ren)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ykADdGwqwpU

Lindsey Jones (voive of Ruby) and Kara Eberle (voice of Weiss)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AEE80lvdkYI




also, here are the voice actresses all cosplaying their characters at RTX:

XcUmOYb.jpg

RTX is going on right now isn't it?

If there are any RT/RWBY panel videos please post them here!
 

coolasj19

Why are you reading my tag instead of the title of my post?
RTX is going on right now isn't it?
If there are any RT/RWBY panel videos please post them here!
lol no. That was July 4th my friend. I know because I went. Butttttttt... If you want RTX videos, I'm happy to oblige.

Lindsey, Kara, Arryn and Barbara In Their Cosplay + RWBY Game.
http://youtu.be/jauy6qfN9uU

RWBY Crew Q&A
http://youtu.be/H_QS7IGf3rE

Jeff and Casey Lee WIlliams - This Will Be That Day
http://youtu.be/Ay0Zq8KIUEU

Jeff and Casey Lee Williams - Wings
http://youtu.be/_ZHxwhcS2UI

Jeff and Casey Lee Williams - Mirror Mirror
http://youtu.be/nfXWwHD07kk

Jeff and Casey Lee Williams - Music Panel
http://youtu.be/GG8VkhY-_0c

They really fucked up this year in terms of archiving. Which peeves me because I skipped the RWBY things I wanted to go to to see GameGrumps stuff with my group, assuming they would archive them like in 2013.
 
lol no. That was July 4th my friend. I know because I went. Butttttttt... If you want RTX videos, I'm happy to oblige.

Lindsey, Kara, Arryn and Barbara In Their Cosplay + RWBY Game.
http://youtu.be/jauy6qfN9uU

RWBY Crew Q&A
http://youtu.be/H_QS7IGf3rE

Jeff and Casey Lee WIlliams - This Will Be That Day
http://youtu.be/Ay0Zq8KIUEU

Jeff and Casey Lee Williams - Wings
http://youtu.be/_ZHxwhcS2UI

Jeff and Casey Lee Williams - Mirror Mirror
http://youtu.be/nfXWwHD07kk

Jeff and Casey Lee Williams - Music Panel
http://youtu.be/GG8VkhY-_0c

They really fucked up this year in terms of archiving. Which peeves me because I skipped the RWBY things I wanted to go to to see GameGrumps stuff with my group, assuming they would archive them like in 2013.

Thanks for the links. I guess they're planning on adding all 4 of the main characters as playable in the game?

It looks like I got RTX and PAX mixed up since that's the one (PAX) that's going on right now. Do you know if they're going to have a panel there as well?
 

naeS

Member
Thanks for the links. I guess they're planning on adding all 4 of the main characters as playable in the game?

It looks like I got RTX and PAX mixed up since that's the one (PAX) that's going on right now. Do you know if they're going to have a panel there as well?

They already did. It was on Friday at Noon PST I think. I don't think there was any news from it though. Not that I have seen/heard yet.
 

coolasj19

Why are you reading my tag instead of the title of my post?
Thanks for the links. I guess they're planning on adding all 4 of the main characters as playable in the game?
It looks like I got RTX and PAX mixed up since that's the one (PAX) that's going on right now. Do you know if they're going to have a panel there as well?
I would assume so. Since they're making it in Unity I hope they port it to some systems that'll be okay with an "okay" game. Like the Vita! Or the 3DS... That way they can bulk up and deliver an amazing PS4 product in a few years.
 
They already did. It was on Friday at Noon PST I think. I don't think there was any news from it though. Not that I have seen/heard yet.

That's too bad. I'm going to take a guess though that the season 3 premiere will be at next years RTX. I think the dates line up correctly if we look at season 1 > 2. Finish current season late in the year, reveal next one at next year's RTX.

I would assume so. Since they're making it in Unity I hope they port it to some systems that'll be okay with an "okay" game. Like the Vita! Or the 3DS... That way they can bulk up and deliver an amazing PS4 product in a few years.

Well PC is a no brainer. Depending on how polished it is I think we could see it on some consoles too.

In terms of features I'd like to see a 4 player coop mode. Actually a 4 on 4 arena mode would be cool too. But those just might be outside the scope of the project.
 
Someone mentioned on Reddit that since Cinder
is based somewhat on Cinderella, it makes sense that something will happen (the "plan" presumably) when the clock strikes 12 in the next episode (during the ball/student dance).

It remains to be seen since that episode isn't out yet but I like all of the little references they've dropped so far (Ruby loving cookies, Yang versus the Ursas/translation of Junior's name, Jaune and Cardin/Joan of Arc and Henry Beaufort, etc).
 

coolasj19

Why are you reading my tag instead of the title of my post?
I'm like 1 day (more like 4 days but w/e) away from getting to the point where I've cheesed Bing Rewards to where I can have enough free Amazon credit to buy RWBY Volume 1. I've always been sad with myself that I didn't ask a question at a RWBY panel at RTX and get myself a free copy there. But now, it's almost time. Then I can see the commentaries and stuff! And watch RWBY whenever I want. Then after that is a Sponsership so I can watch the episodes at a reasonable time. Then after that is saving money for the Soundtrack through Google Surveys.

Yeahhhh... I'm a little bit poor. I'm all on top of that free money companies give out though.

EDIT :
https://m.soundcloud.com/jeff-williams-55/die-rough
This is going to be my favorite track by far when Volume 2 OST is released.
 

Wanderer5

Member
Good to see improvement with Volume 2. Volume 1 was quite a mess heh, but looks like the team are getting the hang of things now. Last epi was quite good
with some sweet action from Pyrrha, Mercury and even CRDL. Too bad the whole Weiss/Pyrrha/Jaune part is still pretty eeeeeh at this point. Also poor Blake is harming herself.D:

And I just realize recently that Monty Oum made Dead Fantasy and Haloid.XD
 

coolasj19

Why are you reading my tag instead of the title of my post?
Good to see improvement with Volume 2. Volume 1 was quite a mess heh, but looks like the team are getting the hang of things now. Last epi was quite good
with some sweet action from Pyrrha, Mercury and even CRDL. Too bad the whole Weiss/Pyrrha/Jaune part is still pretty eeeeeh at this point. Also poor Blake is harming herself.D:
And I just realize recently that Monty Oum made Dead Fantasy and Haloid.XD
I realized who Monty Oum was when I saw this
http://youtu.be/l1mmelrL3r8?t=4m45s
and then saw this
http://youtu.be/ImKCt7BD4U4?t=2m36s
RWBY is like his RvB action scenes on steroids.

I think I finally picked out Jeff Williams when I heard the Black trailer and the first few riffs after "Intruder Alert. Identify Yourself.".
 
I'm like 1 day (more like 4 days but w/e) away from getting to the point where I've cheesed Bing Rewards to where I can have enough free Amazon credit to buy RWBY Volume 1. I've always been sad with myself that I didn't ask a question at a RWBY panel at RTX and get myself a free copy there. But now, it's almost time. Then I can see the commentaries and stuff! And watch RWBY whenever I want. Then after that is a Sponsership so I can watch the episodes at a reasonable time. Then after that is saving money for the Soundtrack through Google Surveys.

Yeahhhh... I'm a little bit poor. I'm all on top of that free money companies give out though.

EDIT :
https://m.soundcloud.com/jeff-williams-55/die-rough
This is going to be my favorite track by far when Volume 2 OST is released.

You might want to wait on that. We still have half of season 2 to go through first. There just might be something that will top it. :p

I realized who Monty Oum was when I saw this
http://youtu.be/l1mmelrL3r8?t=4m45s
and then saw this
http://youtu.be/ImKCt7BD4U4?t=2m36s
RWBY is like his RvB action scenes on steroids.

I think I finally picked out Jeff Williams when I heard the Black trailer and the first few riffs after "Intruder Alert. Identify Yourself.".

I can see where gets his love of highway fight scenes from.

Good to see improvement with Volume 2. Volume 1 was quite a mess heh, but looks like the team are getting the hang of things now. Last epi was quite good
with some sweet action from Pyrrha, Mercury and even CRDL. Too bad the whole Weiss/Pyrrha/Jaune part is still pretty eeeeeh at this point. Also poor Blake is harming herself.D:

And I just realize recently that Monty Oum made Dead Fantasy and Haloid.XD

I can only imagine what they have in store for volume 3. It seems that it's in between seasons/volumes that they have the most time to improve things/add code for stuff like secondary animation/background characters/etc.
 
I realized who Monty Oum was when I saw this
http://youtu.be/l1mmelrL3r8?t=4m45s
and then saw this
http://youtu.be/ImKCt7BD4U4?t=2m36s
RWBY is like his RvB action scenes on steroids.

I think I finally picked out Jeff Williams when I heard the Black trailer and the first few riffs after "Intruder Alert. Identify Yourself.".

I think my favorite Red vs Blue Monty fight is this one:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ke9wtbzGjCI

The choreography isn't as bad-ass as the Project: Freelancer fights, but its so full of personality.
 

coolasj19

Why are you reading my tag instead of the title of my post?
You might want to wait on that. We still have half of season 2 to go through first. There just might be something that will top it. :p
I can see where gets his love of highway fight scenes from.
I can only imagine what they have in store for volume 3. It seems that it's in between seasons/volumes that they have the most time to improve things/add code for stuff like secondary animation/background characters/etc.
But... I can't imagine that right now.
And did you seriously post Falling Towards The Sky episode? That and I Burn were also a massive tell for me. I'm so hungry for another RWBY OST. I'm starving over here!
 

coolasj19

Why are you reading my tag instead of the title of my post?
I think my favorite Red vs Blue Monty fight is this one:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ke9wtbzGjCI
The choreography isn't as bad-ass as the Project: Freelancer fights, but its so full of personality.
Oh hell yeah. The scene where Monty just let's loose. That fight scene made waves across the Internet. Then again, so did RWBY Red Trailer. Oh yeah, and CT and Blake have the exact same
after-image powers
. It's utterly amazing in both.

Edit not : Oh yeah... I was supposed to edit this post into the one before it...
 
But... I can't imagine that right now.
And did you seriously post Falling Towards The Sky episode? That and I Burn were also a massive tell for me. I'm so hungry for another RWBY OST. I'm starving over here!

I'm not sure which episode it's from. I've only seen clips of RvB on youtube.

I'm actually thinking of watching it now. I know that the crazy action doesn't start until the later seasons but it can't hurt to give it a try.

It's also a good opportunity to see what Monty worked on prior to RWBY (which I still need to become a sponsor for so I can watch it early this Thursday!).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom