Ridiculous.schuelma said:I read the SPM review- basically the only complaint with the game was that the "story" interfered with the game/platforming elements too much. The reviewer apparently expected a complete platformer and docked it for having the nerve to still have a story and RPG elements.
SatelliteOfLove said:Super Paper Mario: 8.5
Wario64 said:I'll wait for the Game Informer review before I write off Super Paper Mario.
CO_Andy said:Did Dave just scored Secret Rings a 7, and the critically inferior 360 Sonic a 9?!
Wario64 said:I'll wait for the Game Informer review before I write off Super Paper Mario.
Beezy said:Remember what happened with Paper Mario:TTYD? :/
:lol , PantherLotus or whatever the name is, TOLD YOUR ASS!!!!!schuelma said:I read the SPM review- basically the only complaint with the game was that the "story" interfered with the game/platforming elements too much. The reviewer apparently expected a complete platformer and docked it for having the nerve to still have a story and RPG elements.
With their creditability I'm sure Ami will just commit suicide.Diablos54 said:I fear for Amirox's sanity with a score that low. :lol
:loladg1034 said:
Your always getting shafted, Shidoshi. I still remember your Fighter's Destiny review back in GF :lolshidoshi said:I didn't even realize that I hadn't done any reviews for this issue until reading over that scores list. *laughs* I did a lovely Iris 3 preview, though.
CO_Andy said:Oh, and what's with the overreaction to SPM's score? Seems about right to me: 4/5.
CO_Andy said:Your always getting shafted, Shidoshi. I still remember your Fighter's Destiny review back in GF :lol
Oh, and what's with the overreaction to SPM's score? Seems about right to me: 4/5.
SatelliteOfLove said:Formula One Championship Edition: 9
Wario64 said:I'll wait for the Game Informer review before I write off Super Paper Mario.
It's that crappier games are getting better scores or the same scores which is appalling.CO_Andy said:Your always getting shafted, Shidoshi. I still remember your Fighter's Destiny review back in GF :lol
Oh, and what's with the overreaction to SPM's score? Seems about right to me: 4/5.
Amazing game, nearly perfect in every way, GOTY candidate, but too kiddy for our readers
If that's true then we'd all be trading in our EGMs for a subscription to Dave Magazine.Krowley said:Oh man...
You are WAY out of line with GAF expectations on that one.
9+ is absolutley mandatory. 10's are preferable.
Perhaps we should leave out Dave's scores in these Play review threadsd[-_-]b said:It's that crappier games are getting better scores or the same scores which is appalling.
It's just when comparing it with what the other games got gives us an indication about how good they think the game is.CO_Andy said:Oh, and what's with the overreaction to SPM's score? Seems about right to me: 4/5.
They must be on the Kool-Aid.TMNT: 8.5
BrandNew said:At least it's not as bag as GI's "opinion" on Paper Mario 2.
Nanobreaker is like one of the worst games ever. cant believe they'll give a 9 to that POS.jmdajr said:Sonic and the Secret rings got a lower score than the ps3/360 games.
also
I bought NANObreaker for 2 bux!
Play gave it a 9!
Mr. Spinnington said:So when do play reviews get banned?
Error said:Nanobreaker is like one of the worst games ever. cant believe they'll give a 9 to that POS.
besiktas1 said:It's just when comparing it with what the other games got gives us an indication about how good they think the game is.
Thats why we are reacting, reaction shows we have passion and passion means we're not jaded... so yay for us... but an overwhelming nay for their opinion.
It's a joke, I was trying to make a joke around all the banned sites.shidoshi said:When do people get banned for this stupid crap of suggesting that things should be banned?
What?ramses01 said:Ok, it is a Mario game, that is an automatic 5 point deduction (out of 10) right there before the game is even turned on so ... 8.5 is incredibly generous.
Mr. Spinnington said:It's a joke, I was trying to make a joke around all the banned sites.
Error said:Shidoshi did you give Nanobreaker that score? ;p
Oblivion said:I'm actually surprised Play overrated it.
joke character confirmed?WickedLaharl said:nothing wrong with sharing the same score as sonic 360. it was a good, just not spectacular, game.
Beezy said:Remember what happened with Paper Mario:TTYD? :/
Y2Kevbug11 said:Silverfall must be the worst game ever.
:lol :lolWario64 said:I'll wait for the Game Informer review before I write off Super Paper Mario.