Okay, I read 13 pages of this thread....don't have time for the other 6. I'm in bed writing this and only got 2 hours of sleep last night so forgive me if this sounds awkward...
My initial reaction to this episode was pretty bad. I was very disappointed with it. I'm on the west coast, so I didn't get to live blog with the rest of you, but I did read along with the thread on commercial breaks to get a general idea.
Not surprisingly, my opinion was dead on with 95% of you in here.
When the LOST came up at the end, I was pissed off. That Adam and Even stuff was bullshit. They said 40-50 years in "House of the Rising Sun" and unless there is some time muckery that is going to happen in the next two episodes (Fuck...only two more...) that explains it, it was bullshit.
I think they really fucked it up by not having Rose and Bernard die in there last year. Even if they just retired to the caves and then this season Jack and Hurley see them on their way to the lighthouse and figure it out...that would have been great. If that anagram "The Bones Of Nadlers May Lay Lost In Caves" was actually an answer to a season 6 reveal...that would be some pretty fucking epic foresight by Darlton. Alas, it was not to be. Clearly, to me, they left it open ended and this season decided to revisit it because they had a way to write it in.
Regardless...this episode.
I think the major backlash is all due to the fans. When rumors leaked out that no major cast were going to be in it (And screw the flashback hammer to the brain, that doesn't count), and that it was Jacob/MIB-centric, people started hypothesizing that it would be something that it wasn't meant to be.
This wasn't meant to be the story of how the island came to be. This wasn't the story of how the rules came into play, or how the Egyptians came to the island and built their many landmarks.
As the press release states, this episode was only to share the motives for MIB's current behavior. And really, that's exactly what it did.
Much like Ab Aeterno wasn't about all of the extenuating circumstances surrounding Richard Alpert, only how he got there and his initial dealings with the MIB and Jacob. This was only about the MIB's life leading up to him turning into the Smoke Monster.
Alright, so a couple of things.
1. Seeing this episode made me realize that I really love the main cast. As good as Titus and Mark were in their scenes together, their story isn't something I particularly wanted to see. After "The Candidate" last week, where we got to spend the episode with all of our favorites (sans Ben/Richard/Miles/Desmond) with the shocking conclusion and deaths of some favorite characters, I was ready for more of that story. The story of flight 815 and everything surrounding them is some incredibly compelling stuff and has created some of the greatest characters TV has ever had to offer.
2. After seeing this, and pre-maturely mourning the fall from grace that LOST just endured, I started to realize that the islands mythology really isn't all that important. In all honesty, as Darlton have said time and time again, this isn't about the island, it's about the characters. That's the story they're telling, and they're doing a fine job at it. This made me realize that, really, they don't need to show us everything about the island. The glimpses we got into the core mythology this episode (The 'light', which is clearly electromagnetic based) are really something that needs to be explored on its own. I'm sure Darlton have their reasons why things happen, but unless they shoehorn them in (which they tried to this episode), there really isn't a place for it in the show itself. Without getting a MIB info dump (ala The Architect), there really isn't a way to show the viewer the origins of the island, and the reasoning for everything.
This brought me to start thinking of the encyclopedia. I think this would have been a great place for Darlton to really explore and explain the mythology behind the island (or as much as they feel necessary). It keeps them from having to disappoint viewers by forcing something that doesn't belong or not forcing it, I guess. It allows them to tell the story that is most pertinent (flight 815), while leaving hints of what catalyst the island acts as. While some might say that it would be a cop out, I think it would be an interesting way to expand the life of the franchise past just it's show.
Darlton have done a lot of things like the ARG's, and the mobisodes, and whatnot to build on the foundation of the show. Stuff like the Valenzetti equation, while canon, never had a place in the timeline of the show itself. It's important, in that it helps explain certain things, but it doesn't really affect the losties. So who's to stop them from going into more depth elsewhere? Anyway, that's still not the point of this post.
While initially I was on the 'hate' side of the fence for where LOST was going, as I read more and more I started to fall over to BenjaminBirdie and co's side. Remember in the premiere this season when Locke told Jack that the airline didn't lose Jack's father? They only lost his body? That's what happened in this episode. Jacob killed his brother, and his body is still around, but he is not. As BB and co have been talking about, the smoke monster really does seem like something bigger than just MIB. It seems like this is something that predates Jacob and the mother. This is especially made evident by the Egyptian drawings of the smoke monster. It's clearly something that has been in the island for a long time, and perhaps Jacob's sacrifice of his own innocence led to it being allowed out of the 'light' cave.
I think everything that Jacob told Richard in Ab Aeterno was true. The island really is a cork. It's magnetic properties holds in evil, and evil incarnate is the smoke monster/MIB. It is bound to the island because of this powerful force on the island that is holding it back. It was contained inside that cave for a long time (Jacob's mother had clearly been around for a long time), corked in, if you will, and it wasn't until the body of someone special came floatin' through that it was able to escape again. Jacob knows this now and has made it his mission to keep the monster contained on the island.
This doesn't really jive with the Smoke Monster leaving the island, but I'm not sure how that works. I'm not even sure how Jacob can leave...but whatever. That's another topic altogether.
So while this cave of light seems to be some out of left field bullshit, it actually fits the theme LOST has been plugging away at. And it's not like this is the first time we've seen the light. We saw it in season 2 when Desmond turns the fail safe and we saw it in season 5 when the Losties flash through time. This is just the first time we've seen it contained in one area.
God I'm exhausted. I'm sure this whole post makes no sense and if it does, I'm sure it's already been said in those magic 6 pages I skipped, but I thought I'd get my thoughts out of my head before I forgot. I think there is more in my noggin, but I can't think straight right now.
Anyhoo, I don't think this is the last bit of island information we'll be getting. I certainly think there is more smoke monster reveal than just it coming out of the light cave.
Annnnd, it's bedtime.